Files
dnswatcher/REPO_POLICIES.md
T
clawbotandsneak e77e206fc4
check / check (push) Successful in 55s
next (#136)
Long-lived integration branch. One commit per work unit lands here; this PR accumulates them until it is merged to `main`.

## Landed units

- **Run all linting in Docker via `Dockerfile.lint` + `script/lint`** — #134

    golangci-lint is no longer installed or run on the host. New root `Dockerfile.lint` COPYs the repo into the digest-pinned `golangci/golangci-lint:v2.12.2` image and lints as a build step, so a successful build IS a clean lint; `script/lint` is reduced to a thin wrapper that builds it. This also works where the docker daemon is remote and bind mounts are impossible.

    **Pinned digest and how it was verified.** `golangci/golangci-lint:v2.12.2@sha256:5cceeef04e53efe1470638d4b4b4f5ceefd574955ab3941b2d9a68a8c9ad5240`, exactly as quoted in the issue. It resolves, and it is genuinely v2.12.2:

    ```
    $ docker buildx imagetools inspect golangci/golangci-lint:v2.12.2
    Name:      docker.io/golangci/golangci-lint:v2.12.2
    MediaType: application/vnd.oci.image.index.v1+json
    Digest:    sha256:5cceeef04e53efe1470638d4b4b4f5ceefd574955ab3941b2d9a68a8c9ad5240

    $ docker run --rm golangci/golangci-lint@sha256:5cceeef04e...ad5240 golangci-lint --version
    golangci-lint has version 2.12.2 built with go1.26.2 from c0d3ddc9 on 2026-05-06T11:07:58Z
    ```

    The tag's index digest is the quoted digest, and the binary inside reports commit `c0d3ddc9`, matching the org's canonical pin `c0d3ddc9cf3faa61a4e378e879ece580256d76e5`.

    **Forcing the linter to actually run.** `Dockerfile.lint` is split into a `deps` stage (base image + `go mod download`) and a `lint` stage (source copy + linter run). `script/lint` runs:

    ```
    docker build --progress=plain --no-cache-filter=lint --target lint -f Dockerfile.lint .
    ```

    Caching is explicitly waived for linting, and a cached build lints nothing, so the `lint` stage is invalidated on every invocation. The invalidation is scoped: the `deps` stage stays cached and no global cache wipe is performed. `--progress=plain` keeps the linter's own output visible.

    **`golangci-lint config verify`: deliberately NOT included.** It fetches its JSON schema over a live, unpinned HTTPS call, which would make linting network-dependent and defeat hash-pinning. Omitted for that reason, and the reason is recorded in a comment at the top of `Dockerfile.lint`.

    **`script/bootstrap`** no longer installs golangci-lint (and its pinned ref is gone); it warns non-fatally when `docker` is absent instead. The `goimports` install stays, because `script/fmt` and `script/fmt-check` still run on the host. Header comment updated accordingly.

    **Root `Dockerfile`** — required consequence, not scope creep. Its builder stage ran `make check`, which now calls `script/lint`, which shells out to `docker build`; there is no docker daemon inside a docker build, so `script/cibuild` and `script/docker` would have broken. It gains its own lint stage on the same pinned image (linter invoked directly, with a comment explaining why not `make lint`), with the builder stage depending on it via `COPY --from=lint /src/go.sum /dev/null` and running `make fmt-check`, `make test`, `make build`. The now-unneeded golangci-lint install is gone from the builder stage.

    **README** `Entrypoints` and `Building` sections now describe linting as a docker-only operation. `TODO.md` updated in the same commit.

    ### Verification

    All runs via `make` / `script/` entrypoints only.

    Two consecutive `make lint` runs on an unchanged tree, both executing the linter:

    ```
    # run 1
    #10 [lint 2/2] RUN golangci-lint run --config .golangci.yml ./...
    #10 10.98 0 issues.
    #10 DONE 12.0s

    # run 2, tree untouched
    #10 [lint 2/2] RUN golangci-lint run --config .golangci.yml ./...
    #10 14.63 0 issues.
    ```

    A third run shows the cache scoping is working as intended — `deps` served from cache, `lint` re-executed:

    ```
    #6 [deps 2/4] WORKDIR /src
    #6 CACHED
    #7 [deps 3/4] COPY go.mod go.sum ./
    #7 CACHED
    #8 [deps 4/4] RUN go mod download
    #8 CACHED
    #9 [lint 1/2] COPY . .
    #10 [lint 2/2] RUN golangci-lint run --config .golangci.yml ./...
    ```

    **Negative control.** A deliberate violation (an unused function containing an ineffectual assignment) was added to `internal/config/config.go`:

    ```
    #10 11.26 internal/config/config.go:29:2: ineffectual assignment to x (ineffassign)
    #10 11.26 internal/config/config.go:28:6: func negativeControlUnused is unused (unused)
    #10 11.26 2 issues:
    #10 ERROR: process "/bin/sh -c golangci-lint run --config .golangci.yml ./..." did not complete successfully: exit code: 1
    ERROR: failed to build: failed to solve: process "/bin/sh -c golangci-lint run --config .golangci.yml ./..." did not complete successfully: exit code: 1
    make: *** [Makefile:26: lint] Error 1
    ```

    `make lint` exited non-zero naming both findings and their exact lines. After reverting the file, `make lint` was clean again (`0 issues.`).

    **`make check`** green end to end (test, lint, fmt-check), exit 0.

    **`script/cibuild`** green, confirming the `Dockerfile` restructure does not recurse: the lint stage ran (`#16 12.56 0 issues.`), then `#22 [builder 8/9] RUN make test` with `PASS` lines, then `#23 [builder 9/9] RUN make build`.

    ### Notes for the owner

    This supersedes two PRs you still have queued for merge, both of which tune host linting that no longer exists after this change: #128 (isolates the host golangci-lint cache and lock) and #131 (always installs the pinned lint tools in `script/bootstrap`). Neither was merged or incorporated here.

    Made moot by this change: #121 and #130.

    ### Review outcome

    Reviewed at #136 (comment) — **PASS**. Three non-blocking comment-accuracy findings were recorded there for the next touch of those files; the reviewer independently confirmed the lint gate is live by negative control from a warm cache.

- **Live DNS tests made robust instead of gated; test caps moved to the org-wide 60s/20s/90s values** — #93

    The resolver's live-DNS tests failed nondeterministically, a different subset each run. Fixed by engineering the nondeterminism out, not by routing around the network. **Nothing is mocked, faked, stubbed, recorded or replayed; there is no `-short` flag, no build tag, no skip, and no environment-tolerance for restricted egress.** Production resolver behaviour is unchanged.

    ### Root causes, all test-side

    1. **Burst fan-out at one root server.** Every test in `internal/resolver` calls `t.Parallel()` and the build hosts have many cores (48 here), so all ~35 iterative resolutions started within milliseconds of each other, and because `queryServers` walks `rootServerList()` in fixed order they all aimed their first query at `198.41.0.4`. Root servers rate-limit that, which fits the reported symptom of a different arbitrary subset failing each run.
    2. **No retry anywhere.** One dropped UDP packet in a delegation chain failed a test outright.
    3. **Unanimity assertions.** `TestQueryAllNameservers_AllReturnOK` and `_NXDomainFromAllNS` required *every* nameserver of a domain to answer — four independent chances to fail per run, with no tolerance for one being slow.

    ### What was built

    New `internal/resolver/livedns_test.go` holds all the live-DNS machinery, so `resolver_test.go` itself takes only call-site edits:

    - **Bounded live concurrency.** A package-wide semaphore (`liveConcurrency = 6`) caps how many live resolutions are in flight at once. Tests keep `t.Parallel()`; only their network work is throttled. This is the direct fix for cause 1, and the 60s budget is what makes it affordable.
    - **Retry with exponential backoff.** Three attempts per live operation, 8s deadline each, 500ms base backoff doubling. The retry predicate is deliberately **transport-level** — "did a nameserver answer at all" — and never the assertion the test is making, so a resolver that answers *incorrectly* still fails on the first attempt rather than being retried into a false green.
    - **Quorum instead of unanimity, tolerating SILENCE ONLY.** A strict majority of the discovered nameservers must answer as expected, and every individual result must additionally fall inside a closed **allowlist** of statuses the test explicitly sanctions: `ok`/`timeout`/`error` for the all-OK test, `nxdomain`/`timeout`/`error` for the NXDOMAIN test. A nameserver that stays silent is tolerated; one that answers **wrongly** is not, at any count. The allowlist is the load-bearing part — see the rework note below for why a blocklist was not enough.

    New `internal/resolver/livedns_harness_test.go` tests that machinery directly — quorum arithmetic, status counting, the allowlist, the gate's concurrency bound, per-attempt deadlines, and recovery from a transient failure. It performs no DNS resolution of any kind, so it neither mocks DNS nor depends on it.

    ### Rework after review — the quorum could not fail on a wrong answer

    The review at #136 (comment) returned **FAIL** on `9cb2c2b`, correctly. Fixed in `87bce43`.

    **The defect.** The claim above was, as first written, false for `resolver.StatusNoData`. Each test banned exactly one wrong status — `_AllReturnOK` banned only `nxdomain`, `_NXDomainFromAllNS` banned only `ok` — and `nodata` is neither. It is a **wrong answer, not silence**: `answeredCount` counted it as answered, so it did not even trigger a retry, and with a quorum of 3-of-4 a single wrong nameserver slid through undetected. The pre-change unanimity assertions would have caught it. That is robustness work quietly becoming assertion-loosening, which is exactly what this repo cannot afford.

    **The fix.** Tolerance is now an allowlist, not a blocklist of one status. New `unsanctionedStatuses()` returns every per-nameserver result whose status the caller did not explicitly sanction, and each test asserts that list is empty in addition to its quorum. A blocklist bans the one wrong answer its author thought of and silently admits everything else, including any status added to the resolver later; an allowlist fails on anything nobody sanctioned. `answeredCount` was reframed the same way — it now counts the closed set `ok`/`nxdomain`/`nodata`, so an unfamiliar status is treated as silence and can only ever cause a retry and then a loud failure, never a quiet pass.

    **Evidence — the reviewer's exact probe, re-run.** `queryEachNS` in `internal/resolver/iterative.go` was patched to force one of `google.com`'s four nameservers to return `StatusNoData` with empty records. `make test` now goes **red**, naming the offending nameserver and status:

    ```
    exit=2
    --- FAIL: TestQueryAllNameservers_AllReturnOK (1.12s)
        Error:    Should be empty, but was [ns1.google.com.=nodata]
        Messages: every nameserver must answer OK or not answer at all:
                  ns1.google.com.=nodata ns2.google.com.=ok
                  ns3.google.com.=ok ns4.google.com.=ok
    --- FAIL: TestQueryAllNameservers_NXDomainFromAllNS (1.34s)
        Error:    Should be empty, but was [ns1.google.com.=nodata]
        Messages: every nameserver must report NXDOMAIN or not answer at all:
                  ns1.google.com.=nodata ns2.google.com.=nxdomain
                  ns3.google.com.=nxdomain ns4.google.com.=nxdomain
    FAIL  sneak.berlin/go/dnswatcher/internal/resolver  1.704s
    ```

    That is the same input that returned `exit=0` with both tests **passing** under the old assertions. Probe reverted, tree clean, suite green again:

    ```
    exit=0
    ok  sneak.berlin/go/dnswatcher/internal/resolver  4.185s  coverage: 77.1% of statements
    (zero `(cached)` lines)
    ```

    Two harness tests lock the regression in without any probe: three OK plus one `nodata` (quorum satisfied, no NXDOMAIN present — the exact input that used to pass) is reported as unsanctioned, and an unknown status is neither counted as answered nor tolerated.

    Also fixed from the review: the per-attempt deadline assertion in `livedns_harness_test.go` had no lower bound, so it passed for a deadline far shorter than intended. It now asserts the remaining time exceeds `liveAttemptTimeout/2` as well.

    Deliberately **not** done in this rework, per the review and the owner: no `-count=1` in `script/test` (the test-cache issue is real but pre-existing and repo-wide, filed separately); the remaining non-DNS mocks stay for #97; `queryServers` root-ordering stays untouched under #138.

    ### The `-timeout` backstop value: 90s

    Per the ruling at sneak/prompts#41 (comment) the cap is org-wide with two tiers: **60s hard cap for CI green, 20s target, and anything between the two must be filed as an improvement bug.** The backstop is **`90s`**, matching sneak/prompts#42 and preserving the 1.5x backstop-to-cap ratio the old 20s/30s pair had. It must strictly exceed the 60s cap or the cap is unreachable — the old `-timeout 30s` would have killed a 60s-capped suite at half its allowance. Applied to `script/test`; nothing else in the repo carried the old `30s`.

    Worst case for one live operation is 3 attempts x 8s plus ~1.5s of backoff, about 26s — comfortably inside the 90s backstop even if several operations exhaust their attempts at once.

    ### `REPO_POLICIES.md` is re-vendored, not hand-edited

    The file is org-canonical, so it was **copied byte-for-byte** from `prompts/REPO_POLICIES.md` on `sneak/prompts` branch `org-wide-60s-test-cap` (commit `52b5192`) rather than reworded to approximately the same thing. Verified:

    ```
    $ cmp prompts/REPO_POLICIES.md dnswatcher/REPO_POLICIES.md && echo identical
    identical
    $ sha256sum REPO_POLICIES.md
    bcf11c312a1bee18a0e937eb412b51914411c1ab23308b8362409f3f88379ff7
    ```

    **What that byte-identity does and does not certify.** The source branch `org-wide-60s-test-cap` is an **unmerged proposal** — sneak/prompts#42 — not `prompts` `main`. So, precisely:

    - The **60s hard cap and 20s improvement-bug tier ARE the owner's ruling** (sneak/prompts#41 (comment)).
    - The **`90s` backstop is our own proposed number and is NOT ratified** (sneak/prompts#41 (comment)).
    - The vendored text is therefore **the proposed canonical text, pending** sneak/prompts#42. If that PR lands with different numbers, this file must be re-vendored to match; it should not be hand-edited here either way.

    **Known mismatch with this repo's actual state, recorded not papered over.** Re-vendoring also picked up the paragraph at `REPO_POLICIES.md:266-271` mandating that canonical golangci-lint be installed commit-pinned via `go install ...@c0d3ddc9...`. This repo does **not** comply with that mechanism: `cc86473` in this same PR made linting Docker-only, and `script/bootstrap` now installs golangci-lint nowhere. The **version and commit match** (`v2.12.2` / `c0d3ddc9`); the **installation mechanism does not**. The vendored file is org-canonical and must not be edited downstream, so this is being raised upstream for the org text to accommodate Docker-only linting rather than patched here.

    `TESTING.md`'s stale "within the 30-second target" follows to 60. That edit is deliberately a single line so it merges cleanly when #97 lands.

    ### Verification

    All runs through `make` / `script/` entrypoints only; lint runs in Docker.

    **Ten consecutive `make check` runs, all green, none served from cache.** Go's test cache will happily report `ok pkg (cached)` without executing anything, which proves nothing about nondeterminism, so every run was forced to actually execute and each log was checked for zero `(cached)` lines:

    ```
    check#1  exit=0 wall=32s resolver=2.895s fails=0 cached=0
    check#2  exit=0 wall=27s resolver=2.872s fails=0 cached=0
    check#3  exit=0 wall=47s resolver=2.729s fails=0 cached=0
    check#4  exit=0 wall=36s resolver=2.885s fails=0 cached=0
    check#5  exit=0 wall=32s resolver=2.899s fails=0 cached=0
    check#6  exit=0 (harness tests added)      fails=0 cached=0
    check#7  exit=0 wall=41s resolver=2.891s fails=0 cached=0
    check#8  exit=0 wall=36s resolver=2.871s fails=0 cached=0
    check#9  exit=0 wall=26s resolver=2.846s fails=0 cached=0
    check#10 exit=0 wall=46s resolver=2.833s fails=0 cached=0
    ```

    After the rework commit `87bce43`, `make check` green again end to end, zero `(cached)` test lines, Docker lint stage demonstrably executed rather than served from cache:

    ```
    exit=0  cached=0
    #8 [deps 4/4] RUN go mod download
    #8 CACHED
    #10 [lint 2/2] RUN golangci-lint run --config .golangci.yml ./...
    #10 30.72 0 issues.
    ```

    The Docker lint stage was confirmed to execute rather than cache on each run:

    ```
    #8 [deps 4/4] RUN go mod download
    #8 CACHED
    #9 [lint 1/2] COPY . .
    #9 DONE 0.6s
    #10 [lint 2/2] RUN golangci-lint run --config .golangci.yml ./...
    #10 DONE 39.7s
    ```

    **`make test` wall time: 3.6-4.1s** across three timed uncached runs (`4093ms`, `3649ms`, `3729ms`). `internal/resolver` went from 2.0s to ~2.9s — the concurrency gate's cost. That is inside the 20s target, so no improvement bug is owed under the new two-tier rule.

    **Honest note on what these runs do and do not prove.** Live DNS was healthy throughout: **no live-DNS retry fired even once**, and no flake was observed either before or after the change (six pre-change baseline runs were also clean). So these runs demonstrate the change is not itself flaky and does not slow the suite; they do **not** demonstrate recovery from a real DNS failure, because no real DNS failure occurred. The original flakiness is *not reproduced* rather than *shown fixed*. The retry path is instead proven by `TestRetryLiveRecoversFromTransientFailure`, the only source of the single `retrying in 500ms` line in each log:

    ```
    livedns_harness_test.go:90: transient: attempt 1 of 3 failed
        (no answer from live DNS), retrying in 500ms
    ```

    ### Observation, not acted on

    The single most effective remaining lever against root-server rate limiting would be to stop `queryServers` always trying `rootServerList()` in the same order, so that load spreads across all thirteen roots instead of concentrating on `a.root-servers.net`. That is **production** code and this issue scopes the work as test-side, so it was left alone rather than changed quietly. It is now tracked for the owner's decision at #138.

    ### Interaction with #97

    `TESTING.md` and `internal/resolver/resolver_test.go` auto-merge — that PR touches `resolver_test.go` only at the import block and the final timeout-test section, while this change touches the body of the file and adds two new files, and it leaves the mock-`DNSClient` timeout test at the tail of `resolver_test.go` entirely alone since removing it is that PR's job. `TODO.md` does conflict; that PR is already labelled `needs-rebase`, so this adds nothing material to its rebase.

- **Go's test cache disabled, so every `make test` actually queries live DNS** — #139

    `script/test` did not pass `-count=1`, so on an unchanged tree Go served the whole suite from cache: exit 0 in ~0.2s, every package marked `(cached)`, and not one DNS query made. This repo's suite exists to exercise live resolution on every run (`TESTING.md`), so that green asserted nothing — and it is exactly the green used as evidence that a flakiness fix works, since "run it a few times" stops being runs after the first. It had already misled two agents, each of whom forced uncached runs by hand.

    `-count=1` now disables caching on every invocation.

    **The conditional verbose rerun was missing and is added here.** `REPO_POLICIES.md` mandates it; the primary run had been unconditionally `-v`, which is the failure mode the policy exists to prevent (unreadable CI and `docker build` logs on success). Tests now run quiet, and only a failure triggers the `-v` rerun. Two properties matter and both are covered: the rerun carries `-count=1` too, so it cannot replay a cached copy of the failure it is meant to diagnose; and its exit status is discarded in favour of a forced `1`, so a flake that passes the second time cannot turn the build green — the first failure already proved the suite broken.

    **`-timeout 90s` untouched.** It is a deliberate backstop that must strictly exceed the 60s hard cap.

    **No special-casing for the Docker build**, which reaches the same script via `RUN make test`: a fresh container's test cache is empty, so `-count=1` is a no-op there, and carving out an exception would only create a second code path that could drift.

    ### Verification

    **Proven from a warm cache, not a cold one.** The suite was run first to populate the cache, and the pre-change state confirmed:

    ```
    ok  sneak.berlin/go/dnswatcher/internal/config    (cached)  coverage: 92.6% of statements
    ok  sneak.berlin/go/dnswatcher/internal/resolver  (cached)  coverage: 77.1% of statements
    ...8 of 8 packages (cached)...
    real 0m0.203s
    ```

    With the change applied to that same warm cache, three back-to-back runs on an unchanged tree, **zero `(cached)` markers** in all three:

    ```
    # run 1                                          # run 2
    ok  .../internal/config     1.045s               ok  .../internal/config     1.040s
    ok  .../internal/handlers   1.029s               ok  .../internal/handlers   1.021s
    ok  .../internal/notify     1.148s               ok  .../internal/notify     1.252s
    ok  .../internal/portcheck  1.026s               ok  .../internal/portcheck  1.025s
    ok  .../internal/resolver   3.005s               ok  .../internal/resolver   2.846s
    ok  .../internal/state      1.078s               ok  .../internal/state      1.097s
    ok  .../internal/tlscheck   1.067s               ok  .../internal/tlscheck   1.079s
    ok  .../internal/watcher    1.566s               ok  .../internal/watcher    1.544s
    real 0m4.174s                                    real 0m4.015s

    # run 3: grep -c '(cached)' => 0                 real 0m4.519s
    ```

    **Measured uncached wall time: 4.0-4.5s** (was ~0.2s served from cache). Inside the 20s target, so no improvement bug is owed under the two-tier rule at sneak/prompts#41 (comment).

    **`-count=1` composes with `-race` and `-cover`**: both still present in the primary run, and the per-package coverage percentages above are identical to the pre-change values.

    **The failure path was exercised, not assumed.** A purpose-built flaky test that fails on its first run and passes every run after (marker file kept outside the module, so the tree stays byte-identical and a cached result would be served if caching were on) was run through the script:

    ```
    exit code: 1
    --- FAIL: TestFlaky (0.00s)
    FAIL    flakeproof  0.013s
    --- Rerunning with -v for details ---
    --- PASS: TestFlaky (0.00s)
    ok      flakeproof  1.014s
    ```

    Quiet failure, verbose rerun that genuinely re-executed (it passed, so it did not replay the cached `FAIL`), and exit `1` regardless of the rerun passing. Scratch module removed afterwards.

    **`make check` green**, exit 0, with the Docker lint stage demonstrably executed rather than served from cache:

    ```
    #8  [deps 4/4] RUN go mod download
    #8  CACHED
    #10 [lint 2/2] RUN golangci-lint run --config .golangci.yml ./...
    #10 21.36 0 issues.
    #10 DONE 26.2s
    ```

    `README.md` and `TESTING.md` record why the cache is waived, and `TODO.md` is updated in the same commit.

    ### Question for the owner, not filed as a defect

    The Docker lint run emits `The linter 'gomodguard' is deprecated (since v2.12.0) due to: new major version. Replaced by gomodguard_v2.` It is pre-existing and out of this issue's scope. It is not filed as an issue here because `.golangci.yml` tracks the org-canonical config, so switching to `gomodguard_v2` looks like an upstream `sneak/prompts` decision rather than a per-repo fix. Say the word and it gets filed in whichever place you consider canonical.

- **MIT `LICENSE` added; README states the licence** — #102

    The repo had no licence file at all, so publicly readable code was all-rights-reserved by default and nobody could legally use it. `LICENSE` was also the last file missing from `REPO_POLICIES.md`'s required minimum.

    MIT, by standing org policy rather than a per-repo call: any public repo lacking a licence gets MIT, and a private one with no licence is already all-rights-reserved. `sneak/dnswatcher` is public (`private: false` on the Gitea repo record).

    `README.md`'s first line now names the licence, per the Description requirement, and the License section states MIT and points at the file instead of recording the decision as pending. `TODO.md` updated in the same commit.

    ### Verification

    `LICENSE` is the canonical MIT text byte-for-byte with only the copyright line filled in (`Copyright (c) 2026 sneak`) — no clauses added, removed, reworded, or reflowed. It was not typed from memory: the file was copied from an existing verbatim MIT template on disk and only the copyright line edited (`diff` against that template shows that one line and nothing else), then the result was word-diffed against SPDX `MIT.txt` fetched from `spdx/license-list-data`, ignoring only line wrapping and the placeholder — identical.

    `make fmt` did **not** touch `LICENSE`, and cannot: `script/fmt` runs `gofmt -s -w .` and `goimports -w .` only, with no prettier or markdown step in the repo, so no exclusion was needed.

    `make check` green, exit 0. Tests executed rather than replayed (zero `(cached)` lines, `internal/resolver 3.098s`), and the Docker lint stage ran rather than cached:

    ```
    #10 [deps 4/4] RUN go mod download
    #10 CACHED
    #12 [lint 2/2] RUN golangci-lint run --config .golangci.yml ./...
    #12 36.44 0 issues.
    #12 DONE 36.7s
    ```

- **Comment-only corrections in `script/bootstrap`, `script/cibuild`, and `Dockerfile.lint`** — #137

    Follow-up to this PR's own review. Nothing executable changed: the diff touches comment lines, one warning string, and `TODO.md`.

    - `script/bootstrap`'s header justified the pinned `goimports` install by claiming `script/fmt-check` runs it on the host. Verified against the script: `script/fmt-check` runs `gofmt -l .` and nothing else. The header now credits `script/fmt` alone. That `fmt-check` does not verify goimports at all is #119 and was deliberately left alone.
    - `script/cibuild`'s header still said the `Dockerfile` runs `make check`. It now describes the current file: lint stage runs `make fmt-check` and `golangci-lint`, builder stage runs `make test` and `make build`.
    - The `docker`-missing warning was three fragments, each re-prefixed with `bootstrap:` mid-clause. Now one sentence: `bootstrap: WARNING: docker not found; install it to run make lint and make docker.`
    - `Dockerfile.lint`'s comment explained why `golangci-lint config verify` is omitted but read as though the omission were free. It now states the residual risk: unknown top-level keys in `.golangci.yml` are silently ignored, so a mistyped or wrong-schema key lints clean while applying nothing. `config verify` was **not** added — the network-dependence reasoning stands.

    ### Verification

    `make check` green, exit 0. Tests executed rather than replayed (zero `(cached)` lines, `internal/resolver 2.820s`), Docker lint stage executed rather than cached:

    ```
    #8 [deps 4/4] RUN go mod download
    #8 CACHED
    #10 [lint 2/2] RUN golangci-lint run --config .golangci.yml ./...
    #10 13.30 0 issues.
    ```

    Comment-only confirmed by reading the whole diff: no statement, flag, or command changed anywhere.

---

## Issues closed by this merge

The commits on `next` each carry a bare `(closes #N)` in their subject, but the
references in the prose above are full URLs, which Gitea's auto-close parser
does not act on. Listing them here in bare form so the merge to `main`
definitively closes them rather than leaving them open to be re-picked up as
idle work:

Closes #93
Closes #102
Closes #134
Closes #137
Closes #139

Co-authored-by: sneak <sneak@sneak.berlin>
Reviewed-on: #136
Co-authored-by: clawbot <clawbot@noreply.example.org>
Co-committed-by: clawbot <clawbot@noreply.example.org>
2026-09-09 14:57:55 +02:00

417 lines
21 KiB
Markdown

---
title: Repository Policies
last_modified: 2026-08-07
---
This document covers repository structure, tooling, and workflow standards. Code
style conventions are in separate documents:
- [Code Styleguide](https://git.eeqj.de/sneak/prompts/raw/branch/main/prompts/CODE_STYLEGUIDE.md)
(general, bash, Docker)
- [Go](https://git.eeqj.de/sneak/prompts/raw/branch/main/prompts/CODE_STYLEGUIDE_GO.md)
- [JavaScript](https://git.eeqj.de/sneak/prompts/raw/branch/main/prompts/CODE_STYLEGUIDE_JS.md)
- [Python](https://git.eeqj.de/sneak/prompts/raw/branch/main/prompts/CODE_STYLEGUIDE_PYTHON.md)
- [Go HTTP Server Conventions](https://git.eeqj.de/sneak/prompts/raw/branch/main/prompts/GO_HTTP_SERVER_CONVENTIONS.md)
---
- Cross-project documentation (such as this file) must include
`last_modified: YYYY-MM-DD` in the YAML front matter so it can be kept in sync
with the authoritative source as policies evolve.
- **ALL external references must be pinned by cryptographic hash.** This
includes Docker base images, Go modules, npm packages, GitHub Actions, and
anything else fetched from a remote source. Version tags (`@v4`, `@latest`,
`:3.21`, etc.) are server-mutable and therefore remote code execution
vulnerabilities. The ONLY acceptable way to reference an external dependency
is by its content hash (Docker `@sha256:...`, Go module hash in `go.sum`, npm
integrity hash in lockfile, GitHub Actions `@<commit-sha>`). No exceptions.
This also means never `curl | bash` to install tools like pyenv, nvm, rustup,
etc. Instead, download a specific release archive from GitHub, verify its hash
(hardcoded in the Dockerfile or script), and only then install. Unverified
install scripts are arbitrary remote code execution. This is the single most
important rule in this document. Double-check every external reference in
every file before committing. There are zero exceptions to this rule.
- Every repo with software must have a root `Makefile` with these targets:
`make bootstrap`, `make setup`, `make test`, `make lint`, `make fmt` (writes),
`make fmt-check` (read-only), `make check` (runs `test`, `lint`, `fmt-check`),
`make docker`, and `make hooks` (installs pre-commit hook). A model Makefile
is at `https://git.eeqj.de/sneak/prompts/raw/branch/main/Makefile`.
- Repos follow the
[Scripts to Rule Them All](https://github.com/github/scripts-to-rule-them-all)
pattern: the implementation of each Makefile target lives in an executable
script in `script/` (`script/bootstrap`, `script/setup`, `script/test`,
`script/lint`, `script/fmt`, `script/fmt-check`, `script/check`,
`script/docker`), and the Makefile targets are thin shims that call them. The
scripts must be POSIX sh (`#!/bin/sh`, `set -eu`, no bashisms) so they run in
minimal containers (e.g. alpine images have no bash); locate the repo root
with `$(cd "$(dirname "$0")/.." && pwd -P)` and `cd` there before acting. From
the standard's canonical set we use `bootstrap`, `setup` (make the repo ready
for development after a fresh clone: runs `bootstrap`, then
`install-precommit`, plus any repo-specific initialization), `test`, and
`cibuild`. `script/bootstrap` installs all dependencies idempotently and
assumes nothing is present: base tools come from nix, apt, brew, or apk
(detected in that order; apt runs noninteractive). For node it uses the
installed node if present; otherwise it installs a PINNED node version via
nvm, first installing nvm itself if missing — from a hash-verified GitHub
release archive (never `curl | sh`), with bash installed as an explicit
prerequisite since nvm requires bash. yarn is then pinned via
`corepack prepare yarn@<version> --activate`. Never install "latest" or "lts";
always exact versions. `script/cibuild` runs the CI build: it changes to the
repo root and runs `docker build .`; the Gitea workflow calls it. Four further
scripts are our own extensions to the standard: `script/check` runs
`script/test`, `script/lint`, and `script/fmt-check`; `script/precommit` is
what the git pre-commit hook runs, and it calls `script/check`;
`script/install-precommit` installs the git pre-commit hook (the `make hooks`
target shims to it); and `script/projectname` (literally that filename) simply
outputs the project's name. Scripts that need the name call
`script/projectname` — e.g. `script/docker` assembles its image tag from it —
so those scripts stay byte-identical across all repos. Repo-type-specific
pre-commit extras (e.g. `go mod tidy` verification in Go repos) belong in
`script/precommit`, not in the hook itself. Model scripts are at
`https://git.eeqj.de/sneak/prompts/raw/branch/main/script/<name>`. The README
must document the provided scripts in an **Entrypoints** section (see the
README requirements below).
- Always use Makefile targets (`make fmt`, `make test`, `make lint`, etc.)
instead of invoking the underlying tools directly. The Makefile is the single
source of truth for how these operations are run.
- The Makefile is authoritative documentation for how the repo is used. Beyond
the required targets above, it should have targets for every common operation:
running a local development server (`make run`, `make dev`), re-initializing
or migrating the database (`make db-reset`, `make migrate`), building
artifacts (`make build`), generating code, seeding data, or anything else a
developer would do regularly. If someone checks out the repo and types
`make<tab>`, they should see every meaningful operation available. A new
contributor should be able to understand the entire development workflow by
reading the Makefile.
- Every repo should have a `Dockerfile`. All Dockerfiles must run `make check`
as a build step so the build fails if the branch is not green. For non-server
repos, the Dockerfile should bring up a development environment and run
`make check`. For server repos, `make check` should run as an early build
stage before the final image is assembled. Dockerfiles install development
prerequisites by running `script/bootstrap` rather than duplicating installs
inline; COPY `script/` and the dependency manifests (`package.json` +
`yarn.lock`, `go.mod` + `go.sum`, etc.) before running it so the bootstrap
layer stays cached until dependencies change.
- **Dockerfiles must use a separate lint stage for fail-fast feedback.** Go
repos use a multistage build where linting runs in an independent stage based
on the `golangci/golangci-lint` image (pinned by hash). This stage runs
`make fmt-check` and `make lint` before the full build begins. The build stage
then declares an explicit dependency on the lint stage via
`COPY --from=lint /src/go.sum /dev/null`, which forces BuildKit to complete
linting before proceeding to compilation and tests. This ensures lint failures
surface in seconds rather than minutes, without blocking on dependency
download or compilation in the build stage.
The standard pattern for a Go repo Dockerfile is:
```dockerfile
# Lint stage — fast feedback on formatting and lint issues
# golangci/golangci-lint:v2.x.x, YYYY-MM-DD
FROM golangci/golangci-lint@sha256:... AS lint
WORKDIR /src
COPY go.mod go.sum ./
RUN go mod download
COPY . .
RUN make fmt-check
RUN make lint
# Build stage
# golang:1.x-alpine, YYYY-MM-DD
FROM golang@sha256:... AS builder
WORKDIR /src
# Force BuildKit to run the lint stage before proceeding
COPY --from=lint /src/go.sum /dev/null
COPY go.mod go.sum ./
RUN go mod download
COPY . .
RUN make test
ARG VERSION=dev
RUN CGO_ENABLED=0 go build -trimpath \
-ldflags="-s -w -X main.Version=${VERSION}" \
-o /app ./cmd/app/
# Runtime stage
FROM alpine@sha256:...
COPY --from=builder /app /usr/local/bin/app
ENTRYPOINT ["app"]
```
Key points:
- The lint stage uses the `golangci/golangci-lint` image directly (it
includes both Go and the linter), so there is no need to install the
linter separately.
- `COPY --from=lint /src/go.sum /dev/null` is a no-op file copy that creates
a stage dependency. BuildKit runs stages in parallel by default; without
this line, the build stage would not wait for lint to finish and a lint
failure might not fail the overall build.
- If the project uses `//go:embed` directives that reference build artifacts
(e.g. a web frontend compiled in a separate stage), the lint stage must
create placeholder files so the embed directives resolve. Example:
`RUN mkdir -p web/dist && touch web/dist/index.html web/dist/style.css`.
The lint stage should not depend on the actual build output — it exists to
fail fast.
- If the project requires CGO or system libraries for linting (e.g.
`vips-dev`), install them in the lint stage with `apk add`.
- The build stage runs `make test` after compilation setup. Tests run in the
build stage, not the lint stage, because they may require compiled
artifacts or heavier dependencies.
- Every repo should have a Gitea Actions workflow (`.gitea/workflows/`) that
runs `script/cibuild` (which runs `docker build .`) on push. Since the
Dockerfile already runs `make check`, a successful build implies all checks
pass.
- Use platform-standard formatters: `black` for Python, `prettier` for
JS/CSS/Markdown/HTML, `go fmt` for Go. Always use default configuration with
two exceptions: four-space indents (except Go), and `proseWrap: always` for
Markdown (hard-wrap at 80 columns). Documentation and writing repos (Markdown,
HTML, CSS) should also have `.prettierrc` and `.prettierignore`.
- Pre-commit hook: runs `script/precommit`, which calls `script/check`. If local
testing is not possible in the repo, `script/precommit` may skip `script/test`
and run only `script/lint` and `script/fmt-check`. The hook is installed by
`script/install-precommit`; the Makefile must provide a `make hooks` target
that shims to it.
- All repos with software must have tests that run via the platform-standard
test framework (`go test`, `pytest`, `jest`/`vitest`, etc.). If no meaningful
tests exist yet, add the most minimal test possible — e.g. importing the
module under test to verify it compiles/parses. There is no excuse for
`make test` to be a no-op.
- `make test` must complete in under 60 seconds. That is the hard cap, and a
suite that exceeds it fails. Under 20 seconds is the target. A suite between
20 and 60 seconds is still green, but the overage must be filed as an
improvement bug against that repo. Add a 90-second timeout to the test
invocation in the Makefile (`go test -timeout 90s`). The backstop deliberately
sits above the hard cap so that it catches a genuinely hung test rather than a
merely slow one.
- **`make test` should use the conditional verbose rerun pattern.** Run tests
without `-v` (verbose) first. If tests fail, automatically rerun with `-v` to
show full output. This keeps CI logs and `docker build` output clean on
success (just package/suite summaries) while providing full diagnostic detail
on failure (every test case, every assertion). The general shell pattern:
```makefile
test:
@<test-command> || \
{ echo "--- Rerunning with -v for details ---"; \
<test-command-with-v>; exit 1; }
```
Go example:
```makefile
test:
@go test -timeout 90s -race -cover ./... || \
{ echo "--- Rerunning with -v for details ---"; \
go test -timeout 90s -race -v ./...; exit 1; }
```
Python example:
```makefile
test:
@python -m pytest || \
{ echo "--- Rerunning with -v for details ---"; \
python -m pytest -v; exit 1; }
```
The `exit 1` ensures the target always fails after a rerun — the first run
already proved the tests are broken, so the build must not pass even if a
flaky test happens to succeed on the second attempt. The rerun exists solely
for diagnostic output.
- Docker builds must complete in under 5 minutes.
- `make check` must not modify any files in the repo. Tests may use temporary
directories.
- `main` must always pass `make check`, no exceptions.
- Never commit secrets. `.env` files, credentials, API keys, and private keys
must be in `.gitignore`. No exceptions.
- `.gitignore` should be comprehensive from the start: OS files (`.DS_Store`),
editor files (`.swp`, `*~`), language build artifacts, and `node_modules/`.
Fetch the standard `.gitignore` from
`https://git.eeqj.de/sneak/prompts/raw/branch/main/.gitignore` when setting up
a new repo.
- **No build artifacts in version control.** Code-derived data (compiled
bundles, minified output, generated assets) must never be committed to the
repository if it can be avoided. The build process (e.g. Dockerfile, Makefile)
should generate these at build time. Notable exception: Go protobuf generated
files (`.pb.go`) ARE committed because repos need to work with `go get`, which
downloads code but does not execute code generation.
- Never use `git add -A` or `git add .`. Always stage files explicitly by name.
- Never force-push to `main`.
- Make all changes on a feature branch. You can do whatever you want on a
feature branch.
- `.golangci.yml` is standardized and must _NEVER_ be modified by an agent, only
manually by the user. Fetch from
`https://git.eeqj.de/sneak/prompts/raw/branch/main/.golangci.yml`. The
canonical golangci-lint version is v2.12.2 (released 2026-05-06), installed
commit-pinned via
`go install github.com/golangci/golangci-lint/v2/cmd/golangci-lint@c0d3ddc9cf3faa61a4e378e879ece580256d76e5`.
- When pinning images or packages by hash, add a comment above the reference
with the version and date (YYYY-MM-DD).
- Use `yarn`, not `npm`.
- Write all dates as YYYY-MM-DD (ISO 8601).
- Simple projects should be configured with environment variables.
- Dockerized web services listen on port 8080 by default, overridable with
`PORT`.
- **HTTP/web services must be hardened for production internet exposure before
tagging 1.0.** This means full compliance with security best practices
including, without limitation, all of the following:
- **Security headers** on every response:
- `Strict-Transport-Security` (HSTS) with `max-age` of at least one year
and `includeSubDomains`.
- `Content-Security-Policy` (CSP) with a restrictive default policy
(`default-src 'self'` as a baseline, tightened per-resource as
needed). Never use `unsafe-inline` or `unsafe-eval` unless
unavoidable, and document the reason.
- `X-Frame-Options: DENY` (or `SAMEORIGIN` if framing is required).
Prefer the `frame-ancestors` CSP directive as the primary control.
- `X-Content-Type-Options: nosniff`.
- `Referrer-Policy: strict-origin-when-cross-origin` (or stricter).
- `Permissions-Policy` restricting access to browser features the
application does not use (camera, microphone, geolocation, etc.).
- **Request and response limits:**
- Maximum request body size enforced on all endpoints (e.g. Go
`http.MaxBytesReader`). Choose a sane default per-route; never accept
unbounded input.
- Maximum response body size where applicable (e.g. paginated APIs).
- `ReadTimeout` and `ReadHeaderTimeout` on the `http.Server` to defend
against slowloris attacks.
- `WriteTimeout` on the `http.Server`.
- `IdleTimeout` on the `http.Server`.
- Per-handler execution time limits via `context.WithTimeout` or
chi/stdlib `middleware.Timeout`.
- **Authentication and session security:**
- Rate limiting on password-based authentication endpoints. API keys are
high-entropy and not susceptible to brute force, so they are exempt.
- CSRF tokens on all state-mutating HTML forms. API endpoints
authenticated via `Authorization` header (Bearer token, API key) are
exempt because the browser does not attach these automatically.
- Passwords stored using bcrypt, scrypt, or argon2 — never plain-text,
MD5, or SHA.
- Session cookies set with `HttpOnly`, `Secure`, and `SameSite=Lax` (or
`Strict`) attributes.
- **Reverse proxy awareness:**
- True client IP detection when behind a reverse proxy
(`X-Forwarded-For`, `X-Real-IP`). The application must accept
forwarded headers only from a configured set of trusted proxy
addresses — never trust `X-Forwarded-For` unconditionally.
- **CORS:**
- Authenticated endpoints must restrict `Access-Control-Allow-Origin` to
an explicit allowlist of known origins. Wildcard (`*`) is acceptable
only for public, unauthenticated read-only APIs.
- **Error handling:**
- Internal errors must never leak stack traces, SQL queries, file paths,
or other implementation details to the client. Return generic error
messages in production; detailed errors only when `DEBUG` is enabled.
- **TLS:**
- Services never terminate TLS directly. They are always deployed behind
a TLS-terminating reverse proxy. The service itself listens on plain
HTTP. However, HSTS headers and `Secure` cookie flags must still be
set by the application so that the browser enforces HTTPS end-to-end.
This list is non-exhaustive. Apply defense-in-depth: if a standard security
hardening measure exists for HTTP services and is not listed here, it is
still expected. When in doubt, harden.
- `README.md` is the primary documentation. Required sections:
- **Description**: First line must include the project name, purpose,
category (web server, SPA, CLI tool, etc.), license, and author. Example:
"µPaaS is an MIT-licensed Go web application by @sneak that receives
git-frontend webhooks and deploys applications via Docker in realtime."
- **Getting Started**: Copy-pasteable install/usage code block.
- **Entrypoints**: Opens by stating that the repo adheres to the
[Scripts to Rule Them All](https://github.com/github/scripts-to-rule-them-all)
standard (with that link), then documents each provided `script/`
entrypoint and its purpose.
- **Rationale**: Why does this exist?
- **Design**: How is the program structured?
- **TODO**: Update meticulously, even between commits. When planning, put
the todo list in the README so a new agent can pick up where the last one
left off.
- **License**: MIT, GPL, or WTFPL. Ask the user for new projects. Include a
`LICENSE` file in the repo root and a License section in the README.
- **Author**: [@sneak](https://sneak.berlin).
- First commit of a new repo should contain only `README.md`.
- Go module root: `sneak.berlin/go/<name>`. Always run `go mod tidy` before
committing.
- Use SemVer.
- Database migrations live in `internal/db/migrations/` and must be embedded in
the binary.
- `000_migration.sql` — contains ONLY the creation of the migrations
tracking table itself. Nothing else.
- `001_schema.sql` — the full application schema.
- **Pre-1.0.0:** never add additional migration files (002, 003, etc.).
There is no installed base to migrate. Edit `001_schema.sql` directly.
- **Post-1.0.0:** add new numbered migration files for each schema change.
Never edit existing migrations after release.
- All repos should have an `.editorconfig` enforcing the project's indentation
settings.
- Avoid putting files in the repo root unless necessary. Root should contain
only project-level config files (`README.md`, `Makefile`, `Dockerfile`,
`LICENSE`, `.gitignore`, `.editorconfig`, `REPO_POLICIES.md`, and
language-specific config). Everything else goes in a subdirectory. Canonical
subdirectory names:
- `bin/` — executable scripts and tools
- `cmd/` — Go command entrypoints
- `configs/` — configuration templates and examples
- `deploy/` — deployment manifests (k8s, compose, terraform)
- `docs/` — documentation and markdown (README.md stays in root)
- `internal/` — Go internal packages
- `internal/db/migrations/` — database migrations
- `pkg/` — Go library packages
- `share/` — systemd units, data files
- `static/` — static assets (images, fonts, etc.)
- `web/` — web frontend source
- When setting up a new repo, files from the `prompts` repo may be used as
templates. Fetch them from
`https://git.eeqj.de/sneak/prompts/raw/branch/main/<path>`.
- New repos must contain at minimum:
- `README.md`, `.git`, `.gitignore`, `.editorconfig`
- `LICENSE`, `REPO_POLICIES.md` (copy from the `prompts` repo)
- `Makefile`
- `script/` entrypoints (`bootstrap`, `setup`, `projectname`, `test`,
`lint`, `fmt`, `fmt-check`, `check`, `docker`, `cibuild`, `precommit`,
`install-precommit`)
- `Dockerfile`, `.dockerignore`
- `.gitea/workflows/check.yml`
- Go: `go.mod`, `go.sum`, `.golangci.yml`
- JS: `package.json`, `yarn.lock`, `.prettierrc`, `.prettierignore`
- Python: `pyproject.toml`