fix: say an unknown-scale balance the same way on Send and on confirm (closes #377)
check / check (push) Failing after 2s
e2e / e2e-chrome (push) Failing after 2s
e2e / e2e-firefox (push) Failing after 1s

When two addresses' explorer reports disagree on a token's decimals, the
Send screen showed the stored figure while the confirmation screen said
the balance was unknown. One function in send.js now gives both the
balance and scale, so both read `unknown (SYMBOL)`.

The confirmation screen's fee-unknown message names its cause: for an
unknown scale it says the wallet does not know the token's decimal
places and the transaction cannot be sent, instead of asking for a
retry that cannot help. Other causes keep the old sentence.

Model: opus-5-5
This commit was merged in pull request #425.
This commit is contained in:
2026-10-04 15:59:15 +02:00
parent a68f30c480
commit 45f11ee920
6 changed files with 147 additions and 61 deletions
+15 -1
View File
@@ -198,6 +198,19 @@ function show(txInfo) {
$("confirm-amount-fee-error").classList.toggle("hidden", isErc20);
$("confirm-gas-error").classList.toggle("hidden", !isErc20);
// The fee-unknown message names its cause, which is also known here.
// Without the token's scale estimateGas() cannot encode the transfer, so
// the estimate fails every time and going back cannot help; any other
// failure may clear on a retry.
$("confirm-fee-unknown-error").textContent =
isErc20 && txInfo.tokenDecimals == null
? "The network fee could not be estimated, because this wallet" +
" does not know how many decimal places this token uses, so" +
" this transaction cannot be sent."
: "The network fee could not be estimated, so this transaction" +
" cannot be checked against your balance. Please go back and" +
" try again.";
renderValidation(txInfo);
// Reset password field and error
@@ -244,7 +257,8 @@ function renderValidation(txInfo) {
});
// Messages carrying the user's own numbers are built here; the fixed
// sentences live in the reserved elements in index.html.
// sentences live in the reserved elements in index.html, except the
// fee-unknown one, which show() sets.
const messages = [];
if (codes.includes(CODES.AMOUNT_INVALID)) {
messages.push("Please enter a valid amount to send.");
+52 -52
View File
@@ -146,6 +146,50 @@ function renderSendTokenSelect(addr) {
}
}
// The token balance and scale the Send screen states and hands the
// confirmation screen, so the two screens describe the holding the same way.
//
// The scale is resolved the same way balances.js resolved the scale it
// DISPLAYED this token's balance at: bundled list, then the user's tracked
// tokens, then the explorer. The stored tokenBalances[].decimals is the
// explorer's own answer alone, so reading it raw carries a null forward for a
// token the wallet does know the scale of — and displayedDecimals() then throws
// inside estimateGas(), which the confirmation screen reports as an unestimable
// fee. Unsendable, over a scale that was never in doubt
// (https://git.eeqj.de/sneak/AutistMask/issues/349). Still null when nothing
// knows: no fallback.
//
// Resolved WITH `wallets`, which balances.js does not pass: that adds
// explorerDecimals()'s cross-address check, so a contract two addresses report
// different scales for answers null rather than picking one. That check has to
// apply here, because this scale encodes the transfer — it is carried forward
// so the transfer is encoded with the number the user read rather than with
// whatever the contract answers at signing time (see
// src/shared/transferAmount.js). balances.js is formatting one explorer row at
// fetch time and cannot consult a state it is in the middle of replacing.
//
// The two resolutions can therefore differ, and where they do, the stored
// `balance` is a quantity computed at a scale this screen has just declined to
// stand behind. Stating it would leave validateTransfer() checking the amount
// against a number the wallet does not vouch for, so it is withdrawn: unknown
// scale means unknown balance. It is null rather than "0": both screens state
// an unknown balance as unknown, and validateTransfer() treats it as no balance
// to spend from, which is the fail-closed side of an amount nobody can check.
// Only a stored quantity is withdrawn: the "0" for a token that has no row at
// all is an absence of holdings, which is true at every scale.
function tokenBalanceAndDecimals(addr, token) {
const tb = (addr.tokenBalances || []).find(
(t) => t.address.toLowerCase() === token.toLowerCase(),
);
const tokenDecimals = resolveTokenDecimals(token, {
trackedTokens: state.trackedTokens,
wallets: state.wallets,
});
if (!tb) return { tokenBalance: "0", tokenDecimals };
if (tokenDecimals === null) return { tokenBalance: null, tokenDecimals };
return { tokenBalance: tb.balance ?? null, tokenDecimals };
}
function updateSendBalance() {
const addr = currentAddress();
if (!addr) return;
@@ -162,18 +206,16 @@ function updateSendBalance() {
truncateAmountNeverZero(addr.balance || "0") +
" ETH";
} else {
const tb = (addr.tokenBalances || []).find(
(t) => t.address.toLowerCase() === token.toLowerCase(),
);
const symbol = resolveSymbol(
token,
addr.tokenBalances,
state.trackedTokens,
);
// A null balance is a holding whose scale nothing knows. Saying "0"
// for it would be a claim about the amount; the send itself is
// A null balance is a holding whose scale is unknown. Saying a figure
// for it would be a claim about the amount, so it reads as the
// confirmation screen's balance line reads it; the send itself is
// refused later by transferAmountUnits() for the same missing scale.
const bal = tb ? tb.balance : "0";
const bal = tokenBalanceAndDecimals(addr, token).tokenBalance;
$("send-balance").textContent =
bal == null
? "Current balance: unknown (" + symbol + ")"
@@ -240,59 +282,17 @@ function init(_ctx) {
let tokenSymbol = null;
let tokenBalance = null;
// The scale the amount and the balance below are rendered at, carried
// forward so the transfer is encoded with the number the user read
// rather than with whatever the contract answers at signing time. See
// src/shared/transferAmount.js.
let tokenDecimals = null;
if (token !== "ETH") {
const tb = (addr.tokenBalances || []).find(
(t) => t.address.toLowerCase() === token.toLowerCase(),
);
tokenSymbol = resolveSymbol(
token,
addr.tokenBalances,
state.trackedTokens,
);
// null carried through rather than flattened to "0": the confirm
// screen states an unknown balance as unknown, and
// validateTransfer() treats it as no balance to spend from, which
// is the fail-closed side of an amount nobody can check.
tokenBalance = tb ? (tb.balance ?? null) : "0";
// Resolved the same way balances.js resolved the scale it
// DISPLAYED this token's balance at: bundled list, then the user's
// tracked tokens, then the explorer. The stored
// tokenBalances[].decimals is the explorer's own answer alone, so
// reading it raw carries a null forward for a token the wallet
// does know the scale of — and displayedDecimals() then throws
// inside estimateGas(), which the confirmation screen reports as
// an unestimable fee. Unsendable, over a scale that was never in
// doubt (https://git.eeqj.de/sneak/AutistMask/issues/349).
// Still null when nothing knows: no fallback.
//
// Resolved WITH `wallets`, which balances.js does not pass: that
// adds explorerDecimals()'s cross-address check, so a contract two
// addresses report different scales for answers null rather than
// picking one. That check has to apply here, because this value
// encodes a transfer; balances.js is formatting one explorer row
// at fetch time and cannot consult a state it is in the middle of
// replacing.
tokenDecimals = resolveTokenDecimals(token, {
trackedTokens: state.trackedTokens,
wallets: state.wallets,
});
// The two resolutions can therefore differ, and where they do, the
// stored `balance` is a quantity computed at a scale this screen
// has just declined to stand behind. Stating it would leave
// validateTransfer() checking the amount against a number the
// wallet does not vouch for, and — since the unknown-balance path
// is gated on the balance, not on the scale — would leave the
// fee-estimate failure as the only thing on the confirmation
// screen, which says nothing about decimals. Unknown scale means
// unknown balance. Only a stored quantity is withdrawn: the "0"
// for a token that has no row at all is an absence of holdings,
// which is true at every scale.
if (tb && tokenDecimals === null) tokenBalance = null;
({ tokenBalance, tokenDecimals } = tokenBalanceAndDecimals(
addr,
token,
));
}
ctx.showConfirmTx({