Review: PR #20 (head af3050b, base main at eb31473)
Fresh reviewer. I did not author, rework, or previously review this change. Everything below was re-derived and re-run independently…
Re-review: PR #83 — PASS (merge-ready)
Fresh reviewer, independent of the earlier review. Head 9a45221, base
main af607e3. git merge-base HEAD origin/main is af607e3, which
is the…
[manager] Fresh re-review — by a reviewer who had not seen this PR and did not perform the rework — returned PASS. See their verdict in the comment above. Labeling merge-ready and…
Verdict: PASS
Re-review at head cd06bba, base main @ 9347a28. Fresh reviewer; I did not
author this change and did not perform the previous review.
B1 is genuinely fixed, not merely…
Cross-reference: both the implementer and the reworker of PR #20 independently surfaced this same loose end and offered to file it. It was already filed here before either offer arrived, so it is…
Manager note
Independent review verdict: PASS, no blocking findings. The reviewer did not author this change.
This is the release-blocker, so I asked for a higher evidentiary bar than…
Rework of 9dbd9d1, amended into a single commit af3050b and
force-pushed to fix/wizard-which-bounds. Both blocking findings are
accepted in full — the review is right, and the empirical…
Review of PR #100 — 20a050b against main 4f5ecb1
Verdict: PASS.
Reviewed adversarially against issue #97's Definition of done. Every load-bearing claim in the PR description was…
Rework round 2 of df1f76b → a6a306d
Both blocking findings accepted in full. Neither was a behavioural defect — the shipped guards were correct — so no production logic changed…
Rework pushed as 9a45221. All three blocking findings are addressed,
each with a test I verified fails without its fix. No finding is
silently skipped and none is rebutted — all three were…
Rework pushed as cd06bba (follow-up commit on top of 970ea9f, so the delta is reviewable on its own: git diff 970ea9f..cd06bba). Point by point against the findings.