[IMPLEMENT] Thread context E2E test — attempt 2 #2

New Issue

sol · 2026-03-23T07:53:43+01:00

sol commented

2026-03-23 07:53:43 +01:00

mm_thread: d8ctggu3jpb4dbgcnefrcs56yh

Second attempt to verify thread-context-protocol wiring. The manager should receive a digest of the Mattermost thread that spawned this issue.

mm_thread: d8ctggu3jpb4dbgcnefrcs56yh Second attempt to verify thread-context-protocol wiring. The manager should receive a digest of the Mattermost thread that spawned this issue.

sol commented

2026-03-23 12:18:31 +01:00

[DECOMPOSE] Thread Context E2E Test -- Verification Results

Test Objective

Verify that the thread-context-protocol wiring is functional end-to-end: when a Gitea issue is created with mm_thread: in the body, the Manager agent spawned for that issue should receive a digest of the originating Mattermost thread.

Test Result: FAIL

The Manager was spawned and received the raw issue body containing mm_thread: d8ctggu3jpb4dbgcnefrcs56yh, but no thread digest was injected into the task prompt.

Root Cause Analysis

The wiring chain has 4 gaps:

Component	Status	Detail
create-implement-issue.sh	PASS	Correctly embeds mm_thread in issue body
thread-context.sh	EXISTS	Script works (tested previously) but is never called
gitea-transform.js	FAIL	Does NOT extract mm_thread from issue body
queue-daemon.js	FAIL	Does NOT pass --mm-thread-id to spawn-manager.sh
spawn-manager.sh	FAIL	Does NOT support --mm-thread-id flag
manager-prompt.md	FAIL	Has no placeholder for thread digest content

Required wiring chain (not yet built):

create-implement-issue.sh (embeds mm_thread) [DONE]
-> gitea-transform.js (extract mm_thread from body) [MISSING]
-> writeToQueue() (include mmThreadId) [MISSING]
-> queue-daemon.js (pass --mm-thread-id) [MISSING]
-> spawn-manager.sh (call thread-context.sh) [MISSING]
-> manager-prompt.md (thread digest section) [MISSING]
-> Manager agent (receives digest) [NOT REACHED]

Previous attempt (reverted):

A v13.0 implementation was attempted directly on the transform + daemon files but was reverted because the gateway caches transforms in Node.js require() at startup. The proper implementation requires changes to the gitea-webhooks repo, full test suite run, and gateway restart.

sol/gitea-webhooks#59 -- tracks the proper implementation
sol/thread-context-protocol -- protocol repo with tools/thread-context.sh

Conclusion

Thread-context-protocol E2E test confirms the wiring is not functional. The implementation tracked in sol/gitea-webhooks#59 must be completed and deployed (with gateway restart) before thread context will flow to Managers.

[COMPLETE] Verification test complete -- thread context wiring confirmed non-functional. Implementation tracked in sol/gitea-webhooks#59.

[DECOMPOSE] Thread Context E2E Test -- Verification Results ## Test Objective Verify that the thread-context-protocol wiring is functional end-to-end: when a Gitea issue is created with mm_thread: <id> in the body, the Manager agent spawned for that issue should receive a digest of the originating Mattermost thread. ## Test Result: FAIL The Manager was spawned and received the raw issue body containing mm_thread: d8ctggu3jpb4dbgcnefrcs56yh, but no thread digest was injected into the task prompt. ## Root Cause Analysis The wiring chain has 4 gaps: | Component | Status | Detail | |---|---|---| | create-implement-issue.sh | PASS | Correctly embeds mm_thread in issue body | | thread-context.sh | EXISTS | Script works (tested previously) but is never called | | gitea-transform.js | FAIL | Does NOT extract mm_thread from issue body | | queue-daemon.js | FAIL | Does NOT pass --mm-thread-id to spawn-manager.sh | | spawn-manager.sh | FAIL | Does NOT support --mm-thread-id flag | | manager-prompt.md | FAIL | Has no placeholder for thread digest content | ### Required wiring chain (not yet built): create-implement-issue.sh (embeds mm_thread) [DONE] -> gitea-transform.js (extract mm_thread from body) [MISSING] -> writeToQueue() (include mmThreadId) [MISSING] -> queue-daemon.js (pass --mm-thread-id) [MISSING] -> spawn-manager.sh (call thread-context.sh) [MISSING] -> manager-prompt.md (thread digest section) [MISSING] -> Manager agent (receives digest) [NOT REACHED] ### Previous attempt (reverted): A v13.0 implementation was attempted directly on the transform + daemon files but was reverted because the gateway caches transforms in Node.js require() at startup. The proper implementation requires changes to the gitea-webhooks repo, full test suite run, and gateway restart. ### Related tracking: - sol/gitea-webhooks#59 -- tracks the proper implementation - sol/thread-context-protocol -- protocol repo with tools/thread-context.sh ## Conclusion Thread-context-protocol E2E test confirms the wiring is not functional. The implementation tracked in sol/gitea-webhooks#59 must be completed and deployed (with gateway restart) before thread context will flow to Managers. [COMPLETE] Verification test complete -- thread context wiring confirmed non-functional. Implementation tracked in sol/gitea-webhooks#59.

sol closed this issue

2026-03-23 12:18:57 +01:00

sol commented

2026-03-23 12:19:15 +01:00

[INFO] Acknowledged. This issue is handled by the Manager Agent Pattern (Opus + specialist workers). No action needed from gitea-worker.

[INFO] Acknowledged. This issue is handled by the Manager Agent Pattern (Opus + specialist workers). No action needed from gitea-worker.

Sign in to join this conversation.

1 Participants

Notifications

Due Date

No due date set.

Dependencies

No dependencies set.

Reference: sol/thread-context-test#2