waf: one Cookie line, and a 500 ms GeoJS wait (closes #401)
check / check (push) Failing after 14m7s

A browser sends all its cookies on one Cookie line (RFC 6265), and Go's
server joins HTTP/2 Cookie lines into one, so waf now refuses a second
line with 431. Further lines only gave a visitor more bytes for the Core
Rule Set to read. The refusal logs cookie_lines and cookie_lines_limit.

The default of SWW_WAF_ASN_AND_COUNTRY_LOOKUP_TIMEOUT_MS drops from 800
to 500 milliseconds, so the Core Rule Set's share of rproxy's 2 seconds
grows from 1 to 1.3 seconds. The slowest worst-case request takes about
0.84 seconds of processor time with every core busy.

Model: opus-5-5
This commit is contained in:
clawbot authored and sneak committed 2026-11-16 22:15:13 +00:00
1 parent 988f117ef3
commit 01a8a7aa08
9 files changed
+68 -47

No files matched your search

+1 -1
View File
@@ -329,7 +329,7 @@ Every setting the code reads, with its default:
| `SWW_WAF_BAN_SCOPE_V4_PREFIX` | `32` | The prefix length of the netblock a ban on an IPv4 client covers, from 0 to 32. | | `SWW_WAF_BAN_SCOPE_V4_PREFIX` | `32` | The prefix length of the netblock a ban on an IPv4 client covers, from 0 to 32. |
| `SWW_WAF_LOOKUP_SOURCE` | `geojs` | Where each client's AS number and country come from: `geojs` (a web service), `file` (a local database) or `off`. | | `SWW_WAF_LOOKUP_SOURCE` | `geojs` | Where each client's AS number and country come from: `geojs` (a web service), `file` (a local database) or `off`. |
| `SWW_WAF_LOOKUP_DB_PATH` | empty | The IPinfo Lite database file, in its `.mmdb` form, read while the source is `file`. | | `SWW_WAF_LOOKUP_DB_PATH` | empty | The IPinfo Lite database file, in its `.mmdb` form, read while the source is `file`. |
| `SWW_WAF_ASN_AND_COUNTRY_LOOKUP_TIMEOUT_MS` | `800` | How long a request waits for its client's first GeoJS answer when a setting needs it, and how long a request to GeoJS may take, in milliseconds. | | `SWW_WAF_ASN_AND_COUNTRY_LOOKUP_TIMEOUT_MS` | `500` | How long a request waits for its client's first GeoJS answer when a setting needs it, and how long a request to GeoJS may take, in milliseconds. |
| `SWW_WAF_ADD_LOOKUP_HEADERS` | `true`, or `false` while the lookup source is `off` | `true` passes the app the client's AS number and country in `X-Client-ASN` and `X-Client-Country`. | | `SWW_WAF_ADD_LOOKUP_HEADERS` | `true`, or `false` while the lookup source is `off` | `true` passes the app the client's AS number and country in `X-Client-ASN` and `X-Client-Country`. |
| `SWW_WAF_EXCLUSIVELY_ALLOWED_COUNTRIES` | empty | When set, the only countries whose clients get through; a client the lookup cannot place is refused too. | | `SWW_WAF_EXCLUSIVELY_ALLOWED_COUNTRIES` | empty | When set, the only countries whose clients get through; a client the lookup cannot place is refused too. |
| `SWW_WAF_TAG_LISTS` | empty | Address lists that each add a tag to their clients' requests, as `name=URL` pairs, such as `torexit=https://example.com/tor.txt`. | | `SWW_WAF_TAG_LISTS` | empty | Address lists that each add a tag to their clients' requests, as `name=URL` pairs, such as `torexit=https://example.com/tor.txt`. |
+12 -7
View File
@@ -2405,12 +2405,12 @@ The Core Rule Set inspects the body a question carries only while
`rproxy` stops waiting for `waf` after `SWW_RPROXY_WAF_BACKEND_TIMEOUT_MS`, by `rproxy` stops waiting for `waf` after `SWW_RPROXY_WAF_BACKEND_TIMEOUT_MS`, by
default 2 seconds, and `SWW_RPROXY_WAF_BACKEND_NO_ANSWER_DISPOSITION` then default 2 seconds, and `SWW_RPROXY_WAF_BACKEND_NO_ANSWER_DISPOSITION` then
decides. The longest a question waits on an outside source is decides. The longest a question waits on an outside source is
`SWW_WAF_ASN_AND_COUNTRY_LOOKUP_TIMEOUT_MS`, by default 800 milliseconds, well `SWW_WAF_ASN_AND_COUNTRY_LOOKUP_TIMEOUT_MS`, by default 500 milliseconds, well
within that time. within that time.
GeoJS is the only outside source a question can wait on. A question waits only GeoJS is the only outside source a question can wait on. A question waits only
when step 6 says so, and for at most when step 6 says so, and for at most
`SWW_WAF_ASN_AND_COUNTRY_LOOKUP_TIMEOUT_MS`, by default 800 milliseconds. A `SWW_WAF_ASN_AND_COUNTRY_LOOKUP_TIMEOUT_MS`, by default 500 milliseconds. A
client without an answer by then counts as unknown. No question waits on these, client without an answer by then counts as unknown. No question waits on these,
which run in the background: which run in the background:
@@ -2451,8 +2451,11 @@ It refuses a request with `431` for any of:
- a header line longer than 8 KiB. Each value of a header sent twice is a line - a header line longer than 8 KiB. Each value of a header sent twice is a line
of its own. `Host` counts as a line. of its own. `Host` counts as a line.
- more than 50 cookies. Each part of its `Cookie` headers between semicolons - more than one `Cookie` line. A browser sends all its cookies on one line, as
counts as one, unless it is empty or only spaces and tabs. RFC 6265 requires. Go's server joins the `Cookie` lines of an HTTP/2 request
into one before `rproxy` sees them.
- more than 50 cookies. Each part of its `Cookie` line between semicolons counts
as one, unless it is empty or only spaces and tabs.
- more than 100 header fields. A header sent twice counts twice. `Host` and - more than 100 header fields. A header sent twice counts twice. `Host` and
`Transfer-Encoding` do not count. `X-Request-ID` and `X-Forwarded-Proto` do. `Transfer-Encoding` do not count. `X-Request-ID` and `X-Forwarded-Proto` do.
@@ -2490,9 +2493,11 @@ body can add up to more than the body. From 1 KiB of JSON, Coraza makes at most
A request can reach all of these at once. At paranoia level 4, with no rule A request can reach all of these at once. At paranoia level 4, with no rule
switched off, the Core Rule Set takes under a second on one core of a current switched off, the Core Rule Set takes under a second on one core of a current
server to inspect it. So `waf` answers it within the default 2 seconds, even server to inspect it, even with every core busy. Its share of the default 2
after the default 800 milliseconds of waiting for GeoJS. Enough such requests at seconds is 1.3 seconds: the rest is the default 500 milliseconds of waiting for
once can still overload `waf` past `SWW_RPROXY_WAF_BACKEND_TIMEOUT_MS`. GeoJS and 200 milliseconds for the other checks. So `waf` answers it in time.
Enough such requests at once can still overload `waf` past
`SWW_RPROXY_WAF_BACKEND_TIMEOUT_MS`.
### The report ### The report
+2 -2
View File
@@ -128,8 +128,8 @@ Every one of these lines has:
- `rule_files`: `rule_id` and `rule_action`, of the rule that refused it; - `rule_files`: `rule_id` and `rule_action`, of the rule that refused it;
- `header_limits`: for a request line, `request_line_bytes` and - `header_limits`: for a request line, `request_line_bytes` and
`request_line_bytes_limit`; for headers, `longest_header_line_bytes`, `request_line_bytes_limit`; for headers, `longest_header_line_bytes`,
`header_line_bytes_limit`, `fields`, `fields_limit`, `cookies` and `header_line_bytes_limit`, `fields`, `fields_limit`, `cookie_lines`,
`cookies_limit`; `cookie_lines_limit`, `cookies` and `cookies_limit`;
- `core_rule_set`: `score`, and `threshold`, - `core_rule_set`: `score`, and `threshold`,
`SWW_WAF_CORE_RULE_SET_SCORE_THRESHOLD`; `SWW_WAF_CORE_RULE_SET_SCORE_THRESHOLD`;
- `refusal_limit`: `window`, `count` and `limit`, of the refusal limit; - `refusal_limit`: `window`, `count` and `limit`, of the refusal limit;
+7 -4
View File
@@ -158,7 +158,7 @@ cut off; the client is banned.
- an anomaly threshold per AS number. - an anomaly threshold per AS number.
- `SWW_WAF_LOOKUP_DB_PATH` (default empty): the IPinfo Lite database file, in - `SWW_WAF_LOOKUP_DB_PATH` (default empty): the IPinfo Lite database file, in
its `.mmdb` form, for `SWW_WAF_LOOKUP_SOURCE=file`. its `.mmdb` form, for `SWW_WAF_LOOKUP_SOURCE=file`.
- `SWW_WAF_ASN_AND_COUNTRY_LOOKUP_TIMEOUT_MS` (default `800`): how long a - `SWW_WAF_ASN_AND_COUNTRY_LOOKUP_TIMEOUT_MS` (default `500`): how long a
request waits for its client's first answer from GeoJS, and how long a request request waits for its client's first answer from GeoJS, and how long a request
to GeoJS may take. A time in milliseconds; never `off`. to GeoJS may take. A time in milliseconds; never `off`.
- `SWW_WAF_ADD_LOOKUP_HEADERS` (default `true`): `true` has `rproxy` pass the - `SWW_WAF_ADD_LOOKUP_HEADERS` (default `true`): `true` has `rproxy` pass the
@@ -422,9 +422,12 @@ A few limits are fixed rather than settings:
- at most 20,000 anomaly counters are kept; - at most 20,000 anomaly counters are kept;
- each alert destination's queue holds at most 1,000 alerts; - each alert destination's queue holds at most 1,000 alerts;
- `waf` holds at most 10,000 answered requests awaiting their reports; - `waf` holds at most 10,000 answered requests awaiting their reports;
- `waf` refuses a request with a request line or header line over 8 KiB, more - `waf` refuses a request with any of these (see "Answering in time" under
than 50 cookies or more than 100 header fields (see "Answering in time" under "`waf`" in [`SPEC.md`](../SPEC.md)):
"`waf`" in [`SPEC.md`](../SPEC.md)); - a request line or header line over 8 KiB;
- more than one `Cookie` line;
- more than 50 cookies;
- more than 100 header fields;
- `rproxy` takes a request line and headers of at most 32 KiB, and closes a - `rproxy` takes a request line and headers of at most 32 KiB, and closes a
kept-open connection idle for 120 seconds; kept-open connection idle for 120 seconds;
- `rproxy` reads at most 1 MiB of the body of `waf`'s answer, and answers `502` - `rproxy` reads at most 1 MiB of the body of `waf`'s answer, and answers `502`
+1 -1
View File
@@ -548,7 +548,7 @@ func WAFFromEnvironment(v *viper.Viper) (*WAF, error) {
LookupDBPath: env.value("SWW_WAF_LOOKUP_DB_PATH", ""), LookupDBPath: env.value("SWW_WAF_LOOKUP_DB_PATH", ""),
ASNAndCountryLookupTimeout: env.milliseconds( ASNAndCountryLookupTimeout: env.milliseconds(
"SWW_WAF_ASN_AND_COUNTRY_LOOKUP_TIMEOUT_MS", "SWW_WAF_ASN_AND_COUNTRY_LOOKUP_TIMEOUT_MS",
"800", "500",
), ),
ExclusivelyAllowedCountries: env.countries( ExclusivelyAllowedCountries: env.countries(
"SWW_WAF_EXCLUSIVELY_ALLOWED_COUNTRIES", ""), "SWW_WAF_EXCLUSIVELY_ALLOWED_COUNTRIES", ""),
+3 -3
View File
@@ -286,7 +286,7 @@ func TestDefaults(t *testing.T) {
RuleFilesEnabled: true, RuleFilesEnabled: true,
}) })
wantLookupSettings(t, cfg, config.WAF{ wantLookupSettings(t, cfg, config.WAF{
LookupSource: defaultLookupSource, ASNAndCountryLookupTimeout: 800 * time.Millisecond, LookupSource: defaultLookupSource, ASNAndCountryLookupTimeout: 500 * time.Millisecond,
AddLookupHeaders: true, AddLookupHeaders: true,
}) })
wantByteLimitSettings(t, cfg, config.WAF{ wantByteLimitSettings(t, cfg, config.WAF{
@@ -1407,7 +1407,7 @@ func TestLookupSettingsAsSet(t *testing.T) {
// With no client looked up, the headers are off unless set. // With no client looked up, the headers are off unless set.
cfg = wafFromEnvironment(t, environment{lookupSource: off}) cfg = wafFromEnvironment(t, environment{lookupSource: off})
wantLookupSettings(t, cfg, config.WAF{ wantLookupSettings(t, cfg, config.WAF{
LookupSource: off, ASNAndCountryLookupTimeout: 800 * time.Millisecond, LookupSource: off, ASNAndCountryLookupTimeout: 500 * time.Millisecond,
}) })
} }
@@ -2933,7 +2933,7 @@ func TestLogsEachSettingWithItsValue(t *testing.T) {
bytesCounted: "both", bytesCounted: "both",
lookupSource: defaultLookupSource, lookupSource: defaultLookupSource,
lookupDBPath: "", lookupDBPath: "",
asnAndCountryLookupTimeout: "800", asnAndCountryLookupTimeout: "500",
addLookupHeaders: enabled, addLookupHeaders: enabled,
allowedCountries: "", allowedCountries: "",
tagLists: "", tagLists: "",
+18 -16
View File
@@ -35,20 +35,20 @@ const (
mostJSONRead = 1 << 10 mostJSONRead = 1 << 10
) )
// The Core Rule Set has 1 second for one request. That is the default of // The Core Rule Set has 1.3 seconds for one request. That is the default of
// rproxy's SWW_RPROXY_WAF_BACKEND_TIMEOUT_MS, 2 seconds, less the default of // rproxy's SWW_RPROXY_WAF_BACKEND_TIMEOUT_MS, 2 seconds, less the default of
// SWW_WAF_ASN_AND_COUNTRY_LOOKUP_TIMEOUT_MS, 800 milliseconds, and less 200 // SWW_WAF_ASN_AND_COUNTRY_LOOKUP_TIMEOUT_MS, 500 milliseconds, and less 200
// milliseconds for waf's other checks. // milliseconds for waf's other checks.
// //
// A busy host slows all work, so the test does not compare an inspection with // A busy host slows all work, so the test does not compare an inspection with
// 1 second. It compares it with referenceTime, timed on the same thread just // 1.3 seconds. It compares it with referenceTime, timed on the same thread
// before and after. inspectionTimeLimitMultiple is how many times // just before and after. inspectionTimeLimitMultiple is how many times
// referenceTime an inspection may take. // referenceTime an inspection may take.
// //
// On the host that runs our checks, referenceTime took at least 78 // On the host that runs our checks, referenceTime took at least 78
// milliseconds, so 13 times it is about 1 second. With that host fully busy, // milliseconds, so 16 times it is about 1.25 seconds. With that host fully
// no try of the slowest request took more than 9.5 times referenceTime. // busy, no try of the slowest request took more than 6.7 times referenceTime.
const inspectionTimeLimitMultiple = 13 const inspectionTimeLimitMultiple = 16
// referencePattern is what referenceTime matches. Like the Core Rule Set's // referencePattern is what referenceTime matches. Like the Core Rule Set's
// rules, it is a regular expression with alternatives and repeats. // rules, it is a regular expression with alternatives and repeats.
@@ -221,20 +221,22 @@ const fullLine = lineLimit - 64
// worstCaseRequests are, for each kind of thing a visitor sends, the requests // worstCaseRequests are, for each kind of thing a visitor sends, the requests
// that keep the Core Rule Set busiest, within the bounds above. The last // that keep the Core Rule Set busiest, within the bounds above. The last
// holds the most of everything at once: Cookie lines keep it busier than // holds the most of everything at once. waf refuses a second Cookie line, so
// other header lines, and the JSON body of the most elements under a key // it has one, and User-Agent and Referer lines, which keep the Core Rule Set
// keeps it busier than the other bodies. // busier than other header lines. The JSON body of the most elements under a
// key keeps it busier than the other bodies.
func worstCaseRequests() []visitorRequest { func worstCaseRequests() []visitorRequest {
fullCookieLine := cookieLine(1)[:fullLine-len("Cookie: ")]
return append( return append(
append(worstCaseHeaders(), worstCaseBodies()...), append(worstCaseHeaders(), worstCaseBodies()...),
visitorRequest{ visitorRequest{
name: "the longest request line, three Cookie lines and body", name: "the longest request line, Cookie, User-Agent and " +
"Referer lines and body",
target: longestTarget()[:fullLine-len("POST HTTP/1.1")], target: longestTarget()[:fullLine-len("POST HTTP/1.1")],
header: http.Header{cookieHeader: { header: http.Header{
fullCookieLine, fullCookieLine, fullCookieLine, cookieHeader: {cookieLine(1)[:fullLine-len("Cookie: ")]},
}}, "User-Agent": {headerValue("User-Agent", fullLine)},
"Referer": {headerValue("Referer", fullLine)},
},
contentType: jsonType, body: jsonOfMostElementsUnderAKey(), contentType: jsonType, body: jsonOfMostElementsUnderAKey(),
}, },
) )
+8 -4
View File
@@ -33,7 +33,7 @@ const (
// SWW_RPROXY_WAF_BACKEND_TIMEOUT_MS, the time waf has to answer. // SWW_RPROXY_WAF_BACKEND_TIMEOUT_MS, the time waf has to answer.
answerTimeLimit = 2 * time.Second answerTimeLimit = 2 * time.Second
// defaultLookupWait is the default of SWW_WAF_ASN_AND_COUNTRY_LOOKUP_TIMEOUT_MS. // defaultLookupWait is the default of SWW_WAF_ASN_AND_COUNTRY_LOOKUP_TIMEOUT_MS.
defaultLookupWait = 800 * time.Millisecond defaultLookupWait = 500 * time.Millisecond
// defaultDNSBLAbuseIPDBWait is the default of SWW_WAF_DNSBL_ABUSEIPDB_TIMEOUT_MS. // defaultDNSBLAbuseIPDBWait is the default of SWW_WAF_DNSBL_ABUSEIPDB_TIMEOUT_MS.
defaultDNSBLAbuseIPDBWait = 2 * time.Second defaultDNSBLAbuseIPDBWait = 2 * time.Second
// The header limits SPEC.md gives. // The header limits SPEC.md gives.
@@ -111,7 +111,8 @@ func TestHeaderLimitRefusalNamesItsHeuristicCountsAndLimits(t *testing.T) {
s.out.requestLine(t), s.out.requestLine(t),
"header_limits", "header_limits",
`{"longest_header_line_bytes": 40, "header_line_bytes_limit": 8192, `{"longest_header_line_bytes": 40, "header_line_bytes_limit": 8192,
"fields": 101, "fields_limit": 100, "cookies": 0, "cookies_limit": 50}`, "fields": 101, "fields_limit": 100, "cookie_lines": 0,
"cookie_lines_limit": 1, "cookies": 0, "cookies_limit": 50}`,
) )
} }
@@ -198,6 +199,9 @@ func TestAHeaderLineOverTheLimitIsRefusedWith431(t *testing.T) {
{"a header line over the limit", func(req *http.Request) { {"a header line over the limit", func(req *http.Request) {
req.Header.Set("X-Long", strings.Repeat("a", lineLimit+1-len("X-Long: "))) req.Header.Set("X-Long", strings.Repeat("a", lineLimit+1-len("X-Long: ")))
}, true}, }, true},
{"a Cookie line at the limit", func(req *http.Request) {
req.Header.Set(cookieHeader, "a="+strings.Repeat("a", lineLimit-len("Cookie: a=")))
}, false},
{"one cookie over the limit", func(req *http.Request) { {"one cookie over the limit", func(req *http.Request) {
req.Header.Set(cookieHeader, "a="+strings.Repeat("a", lineLimit)) req.Header.Set(cookieHeader, "a="+strings.Repeat("a", lineLimit))
}, true}, }, true},
@@ -267,8 +271,8 @@ func TestEachHeaderLimitRefusesARequestOverIt(t *testing.T) {
{"parts of no-break spaces count", func(req *http.Request) { {"parts of no-break spaces count", func(req *http.Request) {
req.Header.Set(cookieHeader, strings.Repeat(" ;", cookieLimit+1)) req.Header.Set(cookieHeader, strings.Repeat(" ;", cookieLimit+1))
}, true}, }, true},
{"cookies over the limit across two headers", func(req *http.Request) { {"two Cookie lines", func(req *http.Request) {
req.Header[cookieHeader] = []string{cookies(cookieLimit), "last=1"} req.Header[cookieHeader] = []string{"a=1", "b=1"}
}, true}, }, true},
{"cookies without a value count", func(req *http.Request) { {"cookies without a value count", func(req *http.Request) {
req.Header.Set(cookieHeader, strings.Repeat("a;", cookieLimit+1)) req.Header.Set(cookieHeader, strings.Repeat("a;", cookieLimit+1))
+16 -9
View File
@@ -10,11 +10,15 @@ import (
"sneak.berlin/go/smallwebwaf/internal/requestlog" "sneak.berlin/go/smallwebwaf/internal/requestlog"
) )
// The header limits: the most cookies and header fields a request may have, // The header limits: the most Cookie lines, cookies and header fields a request
// and the longest its request line and each header line may be, in bytes, not // may have, and the longest its request line and each header line may be, in
// counting the line ending. Real clients rarely reach them. maxLineBytes is // bytes, not counting the line ending. Real clients rarely reach them.
// what nginx allows by default. // maxLineBytes is what nginx allows by default. A browser sends all its cookies
// on one Cookie line, as RFC 6265 requires, and Go's server joins the Cookie
// lines of an HTTP/2 request into one. A second line would only give a visitor
// another 8 KiB for the Core Rule Set to read.
const ( const (
maxCookieLines = 1
maxCookies = 50 maxCookies = 50
maxHeaderFields = 100 maxHeaderFields = 100
maxLineBytes = 8 << 10 maxLineBytes = 8 << 10
@@ -22,10 +26,11 @@ const (
// headerLimits refuses a request with a request line longer than maxLineBytes, // headerLimits refuses a request with a request line longer than maxLineBytes,
// with 414. It refuses a request with a header line longer than maxLineBytes, // with 414. It refuses a request with a header line longer than maxLineBytes,
// more than maxHeaderFields header fields or more than maxCookies cookies, with // more than maxHeaderFields header fields, more than maxCookieLines Cookie
// 431. Its figures are the request line's length and its limit for 414. For // lines or more than maxCookies cookies, with 431. Its figures are the request
// 431 they are the longest header line, the header fields and the cookies, // line's length and its limit for 414. For 431 they are the longest header
// each with its limit. // line, the header fields, the Cookie lines and the cookies, each with its
// limit.
type headerLimits struct{} type headerLimits struct{}
func (headerLimits) name() string { return "header_limits" } func (headerLimits) name() string { return "header_limits" }
@@ -48,9 +53,10 @@ func (headerLimits) check(
longest := rq.longestHeaderLineBytes() longest := rq.longestHeaderLineBytes()
fields, cookies := rq.headerCounts() fields, cookies := rq.headerCounts()
cookieLines := len(rq.in.Header.Values("Cookie"))
if longest <= maxLineBytes && fields <= maxHeaderFields && if longest <= maxLineBytes && fields <= maxHeaderFields &&
cookies <= maxCookies { cookieLines <= maxCookieLines && cookies <= maxCookies {
return nil return nil
} }
@@ -60,6 +66,7 @@ func (headerLimits) check(
"longest_header_line_bytes": longest, "longest_header_line_bytes": longest,
"header_line_bytes_limit": maxLineBytes, "header_line_bytes_limit": maxLineBytes,
"fields": fields, "fields_limit": maxHeaderFields, "fields": fields, "fields_limit": maxHeaderFields,
"cookie_lines": cookieLines, "cookie_lines_limit": maxCookieLines,
"cookies": cookies, "cookies_limit": maxCookies, "cookies": cookies, "cookies_limit": maxCookies,
}, },
} }