Compare versions when bootstrap installs a pinned tool (closes #28)

The canonical `if missing <tool>; then install; fi` guard tests PATH
presence and never version, so on any already-provisioned machine a pin
is inert and a version bump is a no-op, while the Dockerfile installs the
pinned version into a clean image and CI then disagrees with local about
what the tool is. Comparing versions alone is not enough either: an
installer writes to its own directory while callers resolve through PATH,
so a shadowing binary lets the install succeed and change nothing anyone
sees. REPO_POLICIES.md now states the whole form — exact whole-token
comparison, mis-parse falling through to a reinstall, re-resolution
through PATH after installing, and a call site that prints the version.

Model: opus-5
This commit is contained in:
2026-09-08 04:58:31 +00:00
parent 58f75147be
commit 85bea7681e
2 changed files with 27 additions and 0 deletions

View File

@@ -21,6 +21,11 @@ fmt-check, and commit.
# Completed Steps # Completed Steps
- 2026-09-08: Made a pinned tool in `script/bootstrap` actually reach the host.
`REPO_POLICIES.md` now requires comparing the installed version against the
pin rather than testing `PATH` presence, and re-resolving the binary through
`PATH` after installing, so a version bump cannot be a silent no-op and a
shadowed install cannot report success.
- 2026-09-08: Closed the false green in the canonical CI gate: `script/cibuild` - 2026-09-08: Closed the false green in the canonical CI gate: `script/cibuild`
and `script/docker` now build with `--no-cache`, so the Dockerfile's check and `script/docker` now build with `--no-cache`, so the Dockerfile's check
layers cannot be served from cache on an unchanged tree, and the text claiming layers cannot be served from cache on an unchanged tree, and the text claiming

View File

@@ -300,6 +300,28 @@ style conventions are in separate documents:
v2.12.2 (released 2026-05-06), installed commit-pinned via v2.12.2 (released 2026-05-06), installed commit-pinned via
`go install github.com/golangci/golangci-lint/v2/cmd/golangci-lint@c0d3ddc9cf3faa61a4e378e879ece580256d76e5`. `go install github.com/golangci/golangci-lint/v2/cmd/golangci-lint@c0d3ddc9cf3faa61a4e378e879ece580256d76e5`.
- **`script/bootstrap` installs a pinned tool by comparing versions, never by
testing presence.** An `if ! command -v <tool>; then install; fi` guard tests
`PATH` only, so on an already-provisioned machine the pin is inert and a
version bump is a silent no-op — while the Dockerfile, installing into a clean
image, gets the pinned version, so a local `make check` and `make docker` can
disagree about what the tool even is. The canonical form:
- compares the installed version against the pin over the **whole** version
token; a parser that stops at the first `-` reports `2.12.2` for a host
running `2.12.2-rc1` and skips the install;
- treats absent, non-zero, empty or unrecognised `--version` output as a
mismatch, so the failure direction is a redundant install and never a
skipped one;
- after installing, re-resolves the binary the way callers do — `hash -r`,
then through `PATH`, not through the directory the installer wrote to —
and fails naming the resolved path, since an install that a shadowing
binary hides succeeds while changing nothing any caller sees;
- is actually called, and prints the version on both success paths: a
function defined and never invoked has the same exit status and the same
empty output as one that worked.
Keep it POSIX sh: no arrays, no `[[`, no `grep -P`.
- When pinning images or packages by hash, add a comment above the reference - When pinning images or packages by hash, add a comment above the reference
with the version and date (YYYY-MM-DD). with the version and date (YYYY-MM-DD).