fix: sign and export with each address's own derivation index (closes #510)

Sending, site transactions, site signatures and private key export
derived the key at the address's position in the wallet's list. After
an import whose scan passed over an unused index, or after removing an
address that was not the last, that position named another address's
key.

Each HD and xprv address record now stores the index it was derived at
(at wallet creation, by the import scan, by "+"). getSignerForAddress()
derives at that index, refuses a record without one, and refuses any key
whose address differs from the record's. The confirmation screen signs
as the From address it shows, not the selected one. The export screen
reports a refusal instead of calling the password wrong.

Model: opus-5-5

README.md

@@ -1192,7 +1192,16 @@ The core hierarchy is **Wallets → Addresses**:
       of its stored `xpub` by `src/shared/walletDefects.js`, explained in the
       wallet list, and blocked from signing, sending and private-key export. It
       is never deleted or rewritten.
-- An **address** holds ETH and ERC-20 tokens.
+- An **address** holds ETH and ERC-20 tokens. In an HD or xprv wallet each
+  address record also stores `index`, the derivation index it was made at: 0 for
+  the first address, the index the import scan found it at, or `nextIndex` when
+  "+" added it. An address's `index` and its position in the wallet's list
+  differ once the scan has passed over an unused index or an address has been
+  removed. Sending, site transactions, site signatures and private-key export
+  derive the key at `index`, and refuse it unless it is that address's own key;
+  an HD or xprv address with no valid `index` is refused before anything is
+  derived (`getSignerForAddress()` in `src/shared/wallet.js`). Each refusal is a
+  full sentence naming the address.
 - The user can have multiple wallets, each with multiple addresses (HD) or a
   single address (key).
 
@@ -1518,6 +1527,9 @@ view would leave a wallet one click from deletion.
       change)
     - "Reveal" (wrong password) → full-sentence error on the error line, nothing
       revealed (no screen change)
+    - "Reveal" (correct password, but this address's key is refused, see Data
+      Model) → full-sentence error saying why, nothing revealed (no screen
+      change)
     - "Back" → previous screen (AddressDetail)
     - Settings gear → **Settings**, whose "Back" goes to AddressDetail: leaving
       drops the address the screen was showing, so it also takes the screen off
@@ -1647,6 +1659,13 @@ view would leave a wallet one click from deletion.
       value (`src/shared/transferAmount.js`)
     - "Sign & Send" (wrong password) → "Wrong password." on the password error
       line, no screen change
+    - "Sign & Send" signs as the From address above, not as whichever address is
+      selected: the two are saved separately, so the popup can reopen onto this
+      screen with another address selected. When the selected wallet does not
+      hold the From address → full-sentence error on the password error line,
+      nothing sent (no screen change)
+    - "Sign & Send" (correct password, but the From address's key is refused,
+      see Data Model) → nothing is signed → **ErrorTx** saying why
     - "Back" → **Send**
 
 #### WaitTx (`wait-tx`)
@@ -2110,6 +2129,9 @@ view would leave a wallet one click from deletion.
       shown, exactly as shown, hands the signed transaction to the background to
       broadcast, then → **WaitTx** in the same popup window
     - "Confirm" (wrong password) → error line, no screen change
+    - "Confirm" (correct password, but the From address's key is refused, see
+      Data Model) → full-sentence error on the error line saying why, nothing
+      signed (no screen change)
     - "Reject" → closes popup (returns rejection to background)
     - Popup window closed without answering → the request is rejected with
       EIP-1193 code 4001
@@ -2128,12 +2150,7 @@ view would leave a wallet one click from deletion.
       blocklist)
     - Site origin (bold, scheme and port included) + "wants you to sign a
       message"
-    - Warning box, shown for `eth_sign`: "This site used the older eth_sign
-      method. The data will be signed as a personal message." An `eth_sign`
-      request names the address first and the data second. Its data is signed
-      exactly as a `personal_sign` message is, as an EIP-191 personal message,
-      which is what the Ethereum JSON-RPC specification defines `eth_sign` to
-      return.
+    - Danger warning box (shown for `eth_sign`, which signs a raw hash)
     - Type: "Personal message" or "Typed data (EIP-712)"
     - From: color dot + full address + etherscan link
     - Message: for `personal_sign` and `eth_sign`, the text the message's bytes

src/background/index.js

@@ -988,8 +988,9 @@ async function handleRpc(method, params, origin) {
 
         if (method === "eth_sign") {
             signParams.dangerWarning =
-                "This site used the older eth_sign method. " +
-                "The data will be signed as a personal message.";
+                "\u26a0\ufe0f DANGER: This site is requesting to sign a raw hash. " +
+                "This can be used to sign transactions that drain your funds. " +
+                "Only proceed if you fully understand what you are signing.";
         }
 
         if (findPendingApproval(origin, "sign")) {

src/popup/views/addWallet.js

@@ -184,7 +184,12 @@ async function importMnemonic(ctx) {
         encryptedSecret: encrypted,
         nextIndex: 1,
         addresses: [
-            { address: firstAddress, balance: "0.0000", tokenBalances: [] },
+            {
+                address: firstAddress,
+                index: 0,
+                balance: "0.0000",
+                tokenBalances: [],
+            },
         ],
     };
     state.wallets.push(wallet);
@@ -205,6 +210,7 @@ async function importMnemonic(ctx) {
     if (scan.addresses.length > 1) {
         wallet.addresses = scan.addresses.map((a) => ({
             address: a.address,
+            index: a.index,
             balance: "0.0000",
             tokenBalances: [],
         }));
@@ -299,7 +305,12 @@ async function importXprvKey(ctx) {
         encryptedSecret: encrypted,
         nextIndex: 1,
         addresses: [
-            { address: firstAddress, balance: "0.0000", tokenBalances: [] },
+            {
+                address: firstAddress,
+                index: 0,
+                balance: "0.0000",
+                tokenBalances: [],
+            },
         ],
     };
     state.wallets.push(wallet);
@@ -320,6 +331,7 @@ async function importXprvKey(ctx) {
     if (scan.addresses.length > 1) {
         wallet.addresses = scan.addresses.map((a) => ({
             address: a.address,
+            index: a.index,
             balance: "0.0000",
             tokenBalances: [],
         }));

src/popup/views/approval.js

@@ -725,7 +725,7 @@ function showSignApproval(details) {
             "This message is plain text, not hex, so it cannot be signed.";
     }
 
-    // The warning the background attaches to an eth_sign request.
+    // Display danger warning for eth_sign (raw hash signing)
     const warningEl = $("approve-sign-danger-warning");
     if (warningEl) {
         if (sp.dangerWarning) {
@@ -867,15 +867,15 @@ function gateOnWalletDefect(errorId, buttonId, address) {
     return true;
 }
 
-// Locate the wallet and the address index owning an address. Returns null when
-// no wallet holds it. Approvals look up the address they were raised for, not
-// whichever address is active now: the approval named one account, and signing
-// with another is what verification refuses.
+// Locate the wallet and the stored address record owning an address. Returns
+// null when no wallet holds it. Approvals look up the address they were raised
+// for, not whichever address is active now: the approval named one account,
+// and signing with another is what verification refuses.
 function findWalletFor(address) {
     for (const wallet of state.wallets) {
         for (let i = 0; i < wallet.addresses.length; i++) {
             if (wallet.addresses[i].address === address) {
-                return { wallet, addrIndex: i };
+                return { wallet, addr: wallet.addresses[i] };
             }
         }
     }
@@ -1002,7 +1002,7 @@ function init(_ctx) {
         try {
             const signer = getSignerForAddress(
                 active.wallet,
-                active.addrIndex,
+                active.addr,
                 decryptedSecret,
             );
             // Sign the approved transaction exactly as it was displayed. The
@@ -1130,7 +1130,7 @@ function init(_ctx) {
         try {
             const signer = getSignerForAddress(
                 active.wallet,
-                active.addrIndex,
+                active.addr,
                 decryptedSecret,
             );
             const sp = pendingSignParams;

src/popup/views/confirmTx.js

@@ -547,6 +547,19 @@ function init(_ctx) {
             return;
         }
 
+        // Sign as the From address this screen shows. The selection is saved
+        // apart from this screen, so the popup can reopen onto it with another
+        // address selected.
+        const addr = wallet.addresses.find((a) => a.address === pendingTx.from);
+        if (!addr) {
+            showError(
+                "confirm-tx-password-error",
+                "The selected wallet does not hold the From address above, " +
+                    "so nothing was sent. Please go back and send again.",
+            );
+            return;
+        }
+
         const password = $("confirm-tx-password").value;
         if (!password) {
             showError(
@@ -581,11 +594,7 @@ function init(_ctx) {
 
         let tx;
         try {
-            const signer = getSignerForAddress(
-                wallet,
-                state.selectedAddress,
-                decryptedSecret,
-            );
+            const signer = getSignerForAddress(wallet, addr, decryptedSecret);
             const provider = getProvider(state.rpcUrl, state.networkId);
             const connectedSigner = signer.connect(provider);
 

src/popup/views/exportPrivkey.js

@@ -135,7 +135,18 @@ async function reveal() {
         // decrypt ran, the wipe has already happened, so the key is not
         // even derived, let alone written.
         if (!isCurrentReveal(generation)) return;
-        const signer = getSignerForAddress(wallet, addressIndex, secret);
+        let signer;
+        try {
+            signer = getSignerForAddress(
+                wallet,
+                wallet.addresses[addressIndex],
+                secret,
+            );
+        } catch (e) {
+            // The password was right; it is the key that was refused.
+            showError("export-privkey-password-error", e.message);
+            return;
+        }
         $("export-privkey-password").value = "";
         $("export-privkey-password-section").classList.add("hidden");
         $("export-privkey-value").textContent = signer.privateKey;

src/popup/views/home.js

@@ -354,6 +354,7 @@ function render(ctx) {
             );
             wallet.addresses.push({
                 address: newAddr,
+                index: wallet.nextIndex,
                 balance: "0.0000",
                 tokenBalances: [],
             });

src/shared/wallet.js

@@ -110,16 +110,33 @@ function addressFromPrivateKey(key) {
     return w.address;
 }
 
-function getSignerForAddress(walletData, addrIndex, decryptedSecret) {
+// The signer for `addr`, one of the wallet's stored address records. An HD or
+// xprv address is derived at its own `index`, never at its position in the
+// wallet's list: the two differ once an import scan passes over an unused
+// index, or once an address that is not the last is removed. An HD or xprv
+// record without a valid `index` is refused before anything is derived.
+// Whatever the wallet type, the key is refused unless it is the key of
+// `addr.address`.
+function getSignerForAddress(walletData, addr, decryptedSecret) {
+    if (
+        (walletData.type === "hd" || walletData.type === "xprv") &&
+        !(Number.isInteger(addr.index) && addr.index >= 0)
+    ) {
+        throw new Error(
+            "No derivation index is stored for " +
+                addr.address +
+                ", so its key cannot be derived.",
+        );
+    }
+    let signer;
     if (walletData.type === "hd") {
         const node = HDNodeWallet.fromPhrase(
             decryptedSecret,
             "",
             BIP44_ETH_PATH,
         );
-        return node.deriveChild(addrIndex);
-    }
-    if (walletData.type === "xprv") {
+        signer = node.deriveChild(addr.index);
+    } else if (walletData.type === "xprv") {
         // Checked here rather than through masterXprvOrThrow so the message
         // fits the situation: nobody is importing anything at signing time,
         // and this wallet is already in storage. src/shared/walletDefects.js
@@ -137,9 +154,18 @@ function getSignerForAddress(walletData, addrIndex, decryptedSecret) {
                     "is not a master key, so it cannot sign.",
             );
         }
-        return node.derivePath(BIP44_ETH_PATH).deriveChild(addrIndex);
+        signer = node.derivePath(BIP44_ETH_PATH).deriveChild(addr.index);
+    } else {
+        signer = new Wallet(decryptedSecret);
     }
-    return new Wallet(decryptedSecret);
+    if (signer.address.toLowerCase() !== addr.address.toLowerCase()) {
+        throw new Error(
+            "The key this wallet holds for " +
+                addr.address +
+                " belongs to a different address, so it was not used.",
+        );
+    }
+    return signer;
 }
 
 function isValidMnemonic(mnemonic) {

tests/addressKey.test.js

@@ -0,0 +1,439 @@
+// Sending, a site's signature request and private key export each use the key
+// of the address they name: the key at the index that address was derived at,
+// not the one at its position in the wallet's list. The two differ after an
+// import whose scan passed over an unused index, and after an address that is
+// not the last is removed (https://git.eeqj.de/sneak/AutistMask/issues/510).
+// A send is signed by the From address its confirmation screen shows, whichever
+// address is selected.
+//
+// Driven through the real import, "+" button, address removal, confirmation
+// screen, signature approval screen and export screen, with the node, the vault
+// and the DOM stubbed.
+
+"use strict";
+
+// The addresses the stub node reports a balance for, and the signed
+// transactions it was handed.
+const mockNode = { funded: new Set(), broadcast: [] };
+
+jest.mock("ethers", () => {
+    const actual = jest.requireActual("ethers");
+    class StubProvider {
+        async getBalance(address) {
+            return mockNode.funded.has(address) ? 1n : 0n;
+        }
+        async getTransactionCount() {
+            return 0;
+        }
+        async estimateGas() {
+            return 21000n;
+        }
+        async getFeeData() {
+            return {
+                maxFeePerGas: 20000000000n,
+                maxPriorityFeePerGas: 1000000000n,
+                gasPrice: 10000000000n,
+            };
+        }
+        async getNetwork() {
+            return { chainId: 1n };
+        }
+        async getCode() {
+            return "0x";
+        }
+        async lookupAddress() {
+            return null;
+        }
+        async broadcastTransaction(signed) {
+            mockNode.broadcast.push(signed);
+            return { hash: "0x" + "ab".repeat(32) };
+        }
+    }
+    return { ...actual, JsonRpcProvider: StubProvider };
+});
+
+// No password is hashed: what the wallet stores is the phrase itself.
+jest.mock("../src/shared/vault", () => ({
+    encryptWithPassword: async (secret) => secret,
+    decryptWithPassword: async (secret) => secret,
+}));
+
+// The wait screen polls for a receipt; these tests stop at the broadcast.
+jest.mock("../src/popup/views/txStatus", () => ({
+    showWait: jest.fn(),
+    showError: jest.fn(),
+}));
+
+jest.mock("ethereum-blockies-base64", () => () => "");
+
+global.fetch = jest.fn(() => {
+    throw new Error("tests must not perform network requests");
+});
+
+const {
+    HDNodeWallet,
+    Mnemonic,
+    Transaction,
+    getBytes,
+    verifyMessage,
+} = require("ethers");
+
+// Publicly known development phrase; never fund it.
+const PHRASE = "test test test test test test test test test test test junk";
+// PHRASE's master extended private key, as the xprv import takes it.
+const XPRV = HDNodeWallet.fromSeed(
+    Mnemonic.fromPhrase(PHRASE).computeSeed(),
+).extendedKey;
+const PASSWORD = "correct horse battery staple";
+const RECIPIENT = "0xC0FfEE0000000000000000000000000000c0fFEe";
+// "Hello", as the hex a page sends.
+const MESSAGE = "0x48656c6c6f";
+
+// The address and key at derivation index `index` of PHRASE, worked out with
+// ethers directly rather than through the wallet's own code.
+function derived(index) {
+    return HDNodeWallet.fromPhrase(PHRASE, "", "m/44'/60'/0'/0/" + index);
+}
+
+// ------------------------------------------------------------ DOM stub
+
+function makeElement(id) {
+    const classes = new Set();
+    const el = {
+        id,
+        textContent: "",
+        title: "",
+        value: "",
+        innerHTML: "",
+        disabled: false,
+        style: {},
+        dataset: {},
+        listeners: {},
+        classList: {
+            add: (...names) => names.forEach((n) => classes.add(n)),
+            remove: (...names) => names.forEach((n) => classes.delete(n)),
+            contains: (n) => classes.has(n),
+            toggle: (n, force) => {
+                const on = force === undefined ? !classes.has(n) : force;
+                if (on) classes.add(n);
+                else classes.delete(n);
+                return on;
+            },
+        },
+        addEventListener: (name, fn) => {
+            el.listeners[name] = el.listeners[name] || [];
+            el.listeners[name].push(fn);
+        },
+        querySelectorAll: () => [],
+        appendChild: () => {},
+    };
+    // Views reach for .parentElement to hide whole sections.
+    Object.defineProperty(el, "parentElement", {
+        get: () => node(id + "-parent"),
+    });
+    return el;
+}
+
+function makeDocument() {
+    const els = new Map();
+    return {
+        getElementById(id) {
+            // The debug banner is created on demand by helpers.js; absent
+            // is the state a non-debug, non-testnet popup is in.
+            if (id === "debug-banner") return null;
+            if (!els.has(id)) els.set(id, makeElement(id));
+            return els.get(id);
+        },
+        createElement: () => makeElement("created"),
+        addEventListener: () => {},
+        body: { prepend: () => {} },
+    };
+}
+
+function node(id) {
+    return globalThis.document.getElementById(id);
+}
+
+function click(element) {
+    const event = { stopPropagation: () => {} };
+    return Promise.all((element.listeners.click || []).map((fn) => fn(event)));
+}
+
+// show() starts the fee estimate without awaiting it; this lets it settle.
+async function settle() {
+    for (let i = 0; i < 10; i++) await new Promise((r) => setTimeout(r, 0));
+}
+
+// ------------------------------------------------------------ harness
+
+globalThis.chrome = {
+    storage: { local: { get: async () => ({}), set: async () => {} } },
+};
+
+const { state } = require("../src/shared/state");
+const { removeAddressFromState } = require("../src/shared/walletDelete");
+const addWallet = require("../src/popup/views/addWallet");
+const home = require("../src/popup/views/home");
+const confirmTx = require("../src/popup/views/confirmTx");
+const approval = require("../src/popup/views/approval");
+const exportPrivkey = require("../src/popup/views/exportPrivkey");
+const txStatus = require("../src/popup/views/txStatus");
+
+// What the background answers when the approval window asks which approval it
+// was opened for, and every message the popup sent it.
+let approvalDetails;
+let sent;
+
+// The "+" button of the wallet list's last render. Each render attaches the
+// handler to the buttons it drew, as the browser's fresh list would have.
+let plusButton;
+
+beforeEach(() => {
+    approvalDetails = null;
+    sent = [];
+    mockNode.broadcast = [];
+    globalThis.document = makeDocument();
+    globalThis.window = { close: () => {} };
+    globalThis.chrome = {
+        storage: { local: { get: async () => ({}), set: async () => {} } },
+        runtime: {
+            connect: () => ({ postMessage: () => {} }),
+            sendMessage: (msg, reply) => {
+                sent.push(msg);
+                if (!reply) return;
+                reply(
+                    msg.type === "AUTISTMASK_GET_APPROVAL"
+                        ? approvalDetails
+                        : null,
+                );
+            },
+        },
+    };
+    node("wallet-list").querySelectorAll = (selector) => {
+        if (selector !== ".btn-add-address") return [];
+        plusButton = makeElement("btn-add-address");
+        plusButton.dataset.wallet = "0";
+        return [plusButton];
+    };
+    // The explorer and price lookups these screens start fail offline, and
+    // say so; that is not under test.
+    for (const method of ["log", "warn", "error"]) {
+        jest.spyOn(console, method).mockImplementation(() => {});
+    }
+    txStatus.showError.mockClear();
+
+    state.wallets = [];
+    state.rpcUrl = "https://rpc.example.invalid";
+    state.networkId = "mainnet";
+    state.viewStack = [];
+    state.currentView = "main";
+
+    addWallet.init({
+        renderWalletList: () => {},
+        doRefreshAndRender: () => {},
+        pageClosed: new AbortController().signal,
+    });
+    confirmTx.init({});
+    approval.init({});
+    exportPrivkey.init();
+});
+
+afterEach(() => {
+    jest.restoreAllMocks();
+});
+
+// Import PHRASE on the add-wallet screen, with the stub node reporting a
+// balance at each of `fundedIndices`, and wait for the address scan.
+async function importPhrase(fundedIndices) {
+    mockNode.funded = new Set(fundedIndices.map((i) => derived(i).address));
+    await click(node("tab-mnemonic"));
+    node("wallet-mnemonic").value = PHRASE;
+    node("add-wallet-password").value = PASSWORD;
+    node("add-wallet-password-confirm").value = PASSWORD;
+    await click(node("btn-add-wallet-confirm"));
+}
+
+// The same, importing XPRV on the add-wallet screen's xprv tab.
+async function importXprv(fundedIndices) {
+    mockNode.funded = new Set(fundedIndices.map((i) => derived(i).address));
+    await click(node("tab-xprv"));
+    node("import-xprv-key").value = XPRV;
+    node("add-wallet-password").value = PASSWORD;
+    node("add-wallet-password-confirm").value = PASSWORD;
+    await click(node("btn-add-wallet-confirm"));
+}
+
+// Press the wallet's "+" button on Home.
+async function addAddress() {
+    home.render({
+        doRefreshAndRender: () => {},
+        pageClosed: new AbortController().signal,
+    });
+    await click(plusButton);
+}
+
+// The key the export screen reveals for the address at `position`.
+async function exportedKey(position) {
+    exportPrivkey.show(0, position);
+    node("export-privkey-password").value = PASSWORD;
+    await click(node("btn-export-privkey-confirm"));
+    return node("export-privkey-value").textContent;
+}
+
+// Confirm a send whose From line shows `from`, with the address at position
+// `selected` selected; resolves to the signed transaction the node was handed,
+// or undefined when none was.
+async function confirmSend(from, selected) {
+    state.selectedWallet = 0;
+    state.selectedAddress = selected;
+    confirmTx.show({
+        from,
+        to: RECIPIENT,
+        amount: "0.5",
+        token: "ETH",
+        balance: "1.0",
+    });
+    await settle();
+    node("confirm-tx-password").value = PASSWORD;
+    await click(node("btn-confirm-send"));
+    return mockNode.broadcast.pop();
+}
+
+// Send from the address at `position`, with that address selected, as the Send
+// button leaves it.
+function sendFrom(position) {
+    return confirmSend(state.wallets[0].addresses[position].address, position);
+}
+
+// A site asks the address at `position` to sign MESSAGE; resolves to the
+// response the approval window sent the background.
+async function signFor(position) {
+    const address = state.wallets[0].addresses[position].address;
+    approvalDetails = {
+        type: "sign",
+        origin: "https://dapp.example",
+        isPhishingDomain: false,
+        approvedFrom: address,
+        signParams: {
+            method: "personal_sign",
+            message: MESSAGE,
+            from: address,
+        },
+    };
+    await approval.show(1);
+    node("approve-sign-password").value = PASSWORD;
+    await click(node("btn-approve-sign"));
+    return sent.find((msg) => msg.type === "AUTISTMASK_SIGN_RESPONSE");
+}
+
+describe.each([
+    [
+        "an import whose scan passed over index 3",
+        async () => {
+            await importPhrase([0, 1, 2, 4]);
+        },
+        // Address 4 on Home, derived at index 4.
+        { position: 3, index: 4 },
+    ],
+    [
+        "an xprv import whose scan passed over index 3",
+        async () => {
+            await importXprv([0, 1, 2, 4]);
+        },
+        { position: 3, index: 4 },
+    ],
+    [
+        "removing the middle one of three addresses",
+        async () => {
+            await importPhrase([0]);
+            await addAddress();
+            await addAddress();
+            removeAddressFromState(state, 0, 1);
+        },
+        // Address 2 on Home after the removal, derived at index 2.
+        { position: 1, index: 2 },
+    ],
+])("after %s", (_name, setUp, { position, index }) => {
+    beforeEach(setUp);
+
+    test("the wallet lists the address derived at that index there", () => {
+        expect(state.wallets[0].addresses[position].address).toBe(
+            derived(index).address,
+        );
+    });
+
+    test("export reveals that address's key", async () => {
+        expect(await exportedKey(position)).toBe(derived(index).privateKey);
+    });
+
+    test("a send is signed by that address", async () => {
+        const signed = await sendFrom(position);
+        expect(Transaction.from(signed).from).toBe(derived(index).address);
+    });
+
+    test("a site's signature is made by that address", async () => {
+        const response = await signFor(position);
+        expect(verifyMessage(getBytes(MESSAGE), response.signature)).toBe(
+            derived(index).address,
+        );
+    });
+});
+
+// The selection and the confirmation screen are saved apart, so the popup can
+// reopen onto the screen with another address selected than its From line
+// shows.
+describe("a confirmation screen whose From is not the selected address", () => {
+    beforeEach(async () => {
+        await importPhrase([0, 1]);
+    });
+
+    test("the send is signed by the From address shown", async () => {
+        const signed = await confirmSend(derived(1).address, 0);
+        expect(Transaction.from(signed).from).toBe(derived(1).address);
+    });
+
+    test("nothing is sent when the selected wallet does not hold it", async () => {
+        expect(await confirmSend(derived(5).address, 0)).toBeUndefined();
+        expect(node("confirm-tx-password-error").textContent).toBe(
+            "The selected wallet does not hold the From address above, " +
+                "so nothing was sent. Please go back and send again.",
+        );
+    });
+});
+
+describe("an address whose stored index derives a different address", () => {
+    function refusal() {
+        return (
+            "The key this wallet holds for " +
+            derived(0).address +
+            " belongs to a different address, so it was not used."
+        );
+    }
+
+    beforeEach(async () => {
+        await importPhrase([0]);
+        state.wallets[0].addresses[0].index = 1;
+    });
+
+    test("export reveals nothing and says why", async () => {
+        expect(await exportedKey(0)).toBe("");
+        expect(node("export-privkey-password-error").textContent).toBe(
+            refusal(),
+        );
+    });
+
+    test("nothing is sent", async () => {
+        expect(await sendFrom(0)).toBeUndefined();
+        expect(txStatus.showError).toHaveBeenCalledWith(
+            expect.anything(),
+            null,
+            refusal(),
+        );
+    });
+
+    test("nothing is signed", async () => {
+        const response = await signFor(0);
+        expect(response.signature).toBeUndefined();
+        expect(response.error).toBe(refusal());
+    });
+});

tests/approvalNonce.test.js

@@ -136,7 +136,9 @@ async function openTxApproval(approvedTx) {
             xpub: "xpub-wallet-1",
             encryptedSecret: "encrypted-secret-1",
             nextIndex: 1,
-            addresses: [{ address: FROM, balance: "0", tokenBalances: [] }],
+            addresses: [
+                { address: FROM, index: 0, balance: "0", tokenBalances: [] },
+            ],
         },
     ];
     approval.init({});

tests/approvalVerify.test.js

@@ -1455,7 +1455,11 @@ describe("background population to popup signing to verification", () => {
 
     // What the popup does with it: signs it as given, populating nothing.
     async function popupSigns(approvedTx) {
-        const localSigner = getSignerForAddress(walletData, 0, SIGNER_KEY);
+        const localSigner = getSignerForAddress(
+            walletData,
+            { address: signer.address },
+            SIGNER_KEY,
+        );
         return localSigner.signTransaction({ ...approvedTx });
     }
 
@@ -1550,7 +1554,11 @@ describe("background population to popup signing to verification", () => {
     // address the user has switched to.
     test("the approved from stops the popup signing with another key", async () => {
         const approvedTx = await backgroundPrepares(TX_PARAMS);
-        const otherSigner = getSignerForAddress(walletData, 0, OTHER_KEY);
+        const otherSigner = getSignerForAddress(
+            walletData,
+            { address: other.address },
+            OTHER_KEY,
+        );
         await expect(
             otherSigner.signTransaction({ ...approvedTx }),
         ).rejects.toThrow(/from address mismatch/);

tests/backgroundApproval.test.js

@@ -1606,55 +1606,6 @@ describe("what the approval is verified against", () => {
     });
 });
 
-// eth_sign names the address first and the data second, the reverse of
-// personal_sign, and is answered as the JSON-RPC specification defines it:
-// with an EIP-191 personal message signature over the data, the same
-// signature personal_sign returns
-// (https://git.eeqj.de/sneak/AutistMask/issues/409). The signature below is
-// made by the test; that the sign screen makes the same one is tested in
-// tests/ethSign.test.js.
-describe("eth_sign", () => {
-    test("is read address first, and returns a personal message signature over the data", async () => {
-        const bg = loadBackground();
-        const page = bg.send(
-            {
-                type: "AUTISTMASK_RPC",
-                method: "eth_sign",
-                params: [signer.address, MESSAGE],
-            },
-            { origin: ORIGIN },
-        );
-        await settle();
-        const id = approvalIdIn(bg.created.map((c) => c.url));
-
-        const details = bg.send(
-            { type: "AUTISTMASK_GET_APPROVAL", id },
-            { url: bg.fromPopup.url },
-        );
-        const { signParams } = details.sendResponse.mock.calls[0][0];
-        expect(signParams).toMatchObject({
-            method: "eth_sign",
-            message: MESSAGE,
-            from: signer.address,
-        });
-        expect(signParams.dangerWarning).toBe(
-            "This site used the older eth_sign method. " +
-                "The data will be signed as a personal message.",
-        );
-
-        const signature = await signer.signMessage(
-            Buffer.from(MESSAGE.slice(2), "hex"),
-        );
-        bg.send(
-            { type: "AUTISTMASK_SIGN_RESPONSE", id, approved: true, signature },
-            { url: bg.fromPopup.url },
-        );
-        await settle();
-
-        expect(page.sendResponse).toHaveBeenCalledWith({ result: signature });
-    });
-});
-
 // The interlock must not cost the retry the approval exists to allow.
 describe("the interlock releases a failed attempt", () => {
     test("a retryable failure before the broadcast leaves the approval usable", async () => {

tests/ethSign.test.js

@@ -1,102 +0,0 @@
-// The sign screen signs an eth_sign request the way it signs personal_sign: as
-// an EIP-191 personal message over the bytes of the data
-// (https://git.eeqj.de/sneak/AutistMask/issues/409). Booted through the real
-// popup entry point as the approval window. The background's half, which reads
-// the address first and the data second and checks the signature, is tested in
-// tests/backgroundApproval.test.js.
-
-// Mocked so that no password has to be hashed: the stored secret decrypts to
-// the test key below.
-jest.mock("../src/shared/vault", () => ({
-    decryptWithPassword: jest.fn(),
-    encryptWithPassword: jest.fn(),
-}));
-
-const { Wallet, getBytes } = require("ethers");
-const {
-    bootPopup,
-    cleanupPopup,
-    unversionedValidProfile,
-} = require("./support/popupBoot");
-
-// A published test key, never used for real funds.
-const SIGNER_KEY =
-    "0x59c6995e998f97a5a0044966f0945389dc9e86dae88c7a8412f4603b6b78690d";
-const signer = new Wallet(SIGNER_KEY);
-// "Hello AutistMask", as the hex a page sends.
-const MESSAGE = "0x48656c6c6f204175746973744d61736b";
-const ORIGIN = "https://dapp.example";
-
-afterEach(cleanupPopup);
-
-test("the sign screen answers eth_sign with a personal message signature over the data", async () => {
-    const sent = [];
-    const page = await bootPopup(
-        unversionedValidProfile({
-            wallets: [
-                {
-                    type: "key",
-                    name: "Wallet 1",
-                    encryptedSecret: "encrypted-key",
-                    addresses: [
-                        {
-                            address: signer.address,
-                            balance: "0.0000",
-                            tokenBalances: [],
-                        },
-                    ],
-                },
-            ],
-            activeAddress: signer.address,
-            allowedSites: { [signer.address]: [ORIGIN] },
-        }),
-        {
-            search: "?approval=approval-1",
-            runtime: {
-                connect: () => ({ postMessage: () => {} }),
-                // Answered as the background answers: with the eth_sign
-                // approval this window was opened for, and by handing back
-                // the signature the popup sends.
-                sendMessage: (msg, reply) => {
-                    sent.push(msg);
-                    if (msg.type === "AUTISTMASK_GET_APPROVAL") {
-                        reply({
-                            type: "sign",
-                            origin: ORIGIN,
-                            isPhishingDomain: false,
-                            approvedFrom: signer.address,
-                            signParams: {
-                                method: "eth_sign",
-                                message: MESSAGE,
-                                from: signer.address,
-                            },
-                        });
-                    } else if (msg.type === "AUTISTMASK_SIGN_RESPONSE") {
-                        reply({ signature: msg.signature });
-                    } else {
-                        reply(undefined);
-                    }
-                },
-            },
-        },
-    );
-    globalThis.window.close = jest.fn();
-    const { decryptWithPassword } = require("../src/shared/vault");
-    decryptWithPassword.mockResolvedValue(SIGNER_KEY);
-
-    expect(page.visibleViews()).toEqual(["approve-sign"]);
-    page.node("approve-sign-password").value = "any password";
-    await page.click("btn-approve-sign");
-
-    expect(
-        sent.filter((msg) => msg.type === "AUTISTMASK_SIGN_RESPONSE"),
-    ).toEqual([
-        {
-            type: "AUTISTMASK_SIGN_RESPONSE",
-            id: "approval-1",
-            approved: true,
-            signature: await signer.signMessage(getBytes(MESSAGE)),
-        },
-    ]);
-    expect(globalThis.window.close).toHaveBeenCalled();
-});

tests/wallet.test.js

@@ -416,7 +416,7 @@ describe("extended key depth", () => {
         expect(() =>
             wallet.getSignerForAddress(
                 { type: "xprv" },
-                0,
+                { address: VECTOR_ADDRESSES[0], index: 0 },
                 accountXprv(VECTOR_PHRASE),
             ),
         ).toThrow(/master/i);
@@ -504,7 +504,7 @@ describe("getSignerForAddress", () => {
     test.each([0, 1, 2])("hd wallet, address index %i", (index) => {
         const signer = wallet.getSignerForAddress(
             { type: "hd" },
-            index,
+            { address: VECTOR_ADDRESSES[index], index },
             VECTOR_PHRASE,
         );
 
@@ -515,7 +515,7 @@ describe("getSignerForAddress", () => {
     test.each([0, 1, 2])("xprv wallet, address index %i", (index) => {
         const signer = wallet.getSignerForAddress(
             { type: "xprv" },
-            index,
+            { address: VECTOR_ADDRESSES[index], index },
             masterXprv(VECTOR_PHRASE),
         );
 
@@ -527,7 +527,7 @@ describe("getSignerForAddress", () => {
         for (const index of [0, 1, 2]) {
             const signer = wallet.getSignerForAddress(
                 { type: "privkey" },
-                index,
+                { address: VECTOR_ADDRESSES[1], index },
                 VECTOR_PRIVATE_KEYS[1],
             );
 
@@ -535,10 +535,54 @@ describe("getSignerForAddress", () => {
         }
     });
 
+    // https://git.eeqj.de/sneak/AutistMask/issues/510: an address whose stored
+    // index does not derive it, or a private key that is not its key.
+    test.each([
+        ["hd", { address: VECTOR_ADDRESSES[2], index: 1 }, VECTOR_PHRASE],
+        [
+            "xprv",
+            { address: VECTOR_ADDRESSES[2], index: 1 },
+            masterXprv(VECTOR_PHRASE),
+        ],
+        ["privkey", { address: VECTOR_ADDRESSES[2] }, VECTOR_PRIVATE_KEYS[1]],
+    ])(
+        "%s wallet refuses a key that is not the address's own",
+        (type, addr, secret) => {
+            expect(() =>
+                wallet.getSignerForAddress({ type }, addr, secret),
+            ).toThrow(
+                "The key this wallet holds for " +
+                    VECTOR_ADDRESSES[2] +
+                    " belongs to a different address, so it was not used.",
+            );
+        },
+    );
+
+    // An HD or xprv address record without a usable `index` is refused in a
+    // sentence, not with what ethers says about the value it was handed.
+    test.each([
+        ["hd", VECTOR_PHRASE],
+        ["xprv", masterXprv(VECTOR_PHRASE)],
+    ])("%s wallet refuses an address with no valid index", (type, secret) => {
+        for (const index of [undefined, null, -1, 1.5, "1"]) {
+            expect(() =>
+                wallet.getSignerForAddress(
+                    { type },
+                    { address: VECTOR_ADDRESSES[1], index },
+                    secret,
+                ),
+            ).toThrow(
+                "No derivation index is stored for " +
+                    VECTOR_ADDRESSES[1] +
+                    ", so its key cannot be derived.",
+            );
+        }
+    });
+
     test("the returned signer signs recoverably as the expected address", async () => {
         const signer = wallet.getSignerForAddress(
             { type: "hd" },
-            1,
+            { address: VECTOR_ADDRESSES[1], index: 1 },
             VECTOR_PHRASE,
         );
         const message = "AutistMask derivation test";

tests/walletDefects.test.js

@@ -55,7 +55,7 @@ function healthyXprvWallet(name = "Master") {
         xpub,
         nextIndex: 1,
         encryptedSecret: "irrelevant-to-these-tests",
-        addresses: [{ address: firstAddress, balance: "0.0000" }],
+        addresses: [{ address: firstAddress, index: 0, balance: "0.0000" }],
     };
 }
 
@@ -74,7 +74,11 @@ function brokenXprvWallet(name = "Imported xprv") {
         nextIndex: 1,
         encryptedSecret: "irrelevant-to-these-tests",
         addresses: [
-            { address: node.deriveChild(0).address, balance: "0.0000" },
+            {
+                address: node.deriveChild(0).address,
+                index: 0,
+                balance: "0.0000",
+            },
         ],
     };
 }
@@ -570,7 +574,7 @@ describe("no path throws an unhandled error for a defective wallet", () => {
         try {
             wallet.getSignerForAddress(
                 { type: "xprv" },
-                0,
+                brokenXprvWallet().addresses[0],
                 accountXprv(VECTOR_PHRASE),
             );
         } catch (e) {
@@ -585,7 +589,7 @@ describe("no path throws an unhandled error for a defective wallet", () => {
     test("a healthy xprv wallet signs as it always did", () => {
         const signer = wallet.getSignerForAddress(
             { type: "xprv" },
-            0,
+            healthyXprvWallet().addresses[0],
             masterXprv(VECTOR_PHRASE),
         );