fix: explain a rejected dust threshold instead of snapping back silently (closes #233)
All checks were successful
check / check (push) Successful in 27s

The dust threshold field resynced to the stored value on a rejected input
and said nothing, so the box changed to a different number with no reason
given. It was the only validated input in the settings view that rejected
without a message.

Rejected input now shows one full sentence naming the constraint, using the
flash line already used by the RPC and Blockscout validation in the same
file.

No layout shift, measured rather than asserted: #flash-msg reserves exactly
one line at text-xs (min-h-[1.25rem], 20px), so the message has to fit one
line or it wraps and pushes the settings view down. "Enter a whole number of
gwei, zero or greater." renders at 20px at the documented 360x600 popup
width, identical to the empty line, with the settings view and the threshold
field at the same document position either way.

Hex and exponent notation are rejected rather than accepted. Number() reads
0x10 as 16 and 1e3 as 1000, which the earlier parseInt did not, and storing
either would put a number in the field that the user never typed - the same
silent substitution the message exists to end. Accepted input is plain
decimal digits only; the field is inputmode="numeric" and the unit is
printed beside it.

The parse moves to src/popup/dustThreshold.js, pure and unit tested, with
the message beside it so there is one wording. Unit tests cover the accepted
set, the rejected notations, and that a rejection flashes the message and
stores nothing while a valid value stores and stays quiet.

The layout assertion lives in the e2e suite because it needs a layout
engine: jest runs on the node environment, where every rendered height is
zero, so no unit test can see the message wrap. tests/e2e/run.js drives the
real popup in the pinned Playwright container, types a rejected value,
measures the flash line filled against the same line empty, and fails if the
message grows past one line - verified by lengthening it and watching the
test go red.
This commit is contained in:
2026-08-12 08:59:06 +00:00
parent afe6ddaea0
commit 781a7def17
6 changed files with 438 additions and 8 deletions

243
tests/dustThreshold.test.js Normal file
View File

@@ -0,0 +1,243 @@
// Tests for the dust threshold field in Settings (issue #233).
//
// Two halves: what the parse accepts, and what the settings view does with a
// rejection. The view half runs against the real change handler with the DOM
// helpers stubbed out, because the bug was not in the parse — it was that a
// rejection said nothing.
const {
DUST_THRESHOLD_MESSAGE,
parseDustThresholdGwei,
} = require("../src/popup/dustThreshold");
describe("parsing the dust threshold", () => {
test("accepts a whole number of gwei", () => {
expect(parseDustThresholdGwei("100000")).toBe(100000);
expect(parseDustThresholdGwei("1")).toBe(1);
});
// Zero is a real setting, not an empty field: it hides nothing.
test("accepts zero", () => {
expect(parseDustThresholdGwei("0")).toBe(0);
});
test("accepts surrounding whitespace", () => {
expect(parseDustThresholdGwei(" 250 ")).toBe(250);
});
test("rejects an empty field", () => {
expect(parseDustThresholdGwei("")).toBe(null);
expect(parseDustThresholdGwei(" ")).toBe(null);
});
test("rejects a negative threshold", () => {
expect(parseDustThresholdGwei("-1")).toBe(null);
});
// parseInt used to read this as 1, which is not what was typed.
test("rejects a fractional value", () => {
expect(parseDustThresholdGwei("1.5")).toBe(null);
expect(parseDustThresholdGwei("1.0")).toBe(null);
});
// parseInt used to read this as 100. The unit is printed beside the
// field already.
test("rejects a value carrying its unit", () => {
expect(parseDustThresholdGwei("100 gwei")).toBe(null);
});
// Number() reads this as 16. Storing 16 for a field that was told to
// want a whole number of gwei would be the same silent substitution the
// message exists to end.
test("rejects hex notation", () => {
expect(parseDustThresholdGwei("0x10")).toBe(null);
});
// Number() reads this as 1000.
test("rejects exponent notation", () => {
expect(parseDustThresholdGwei("1e3")).toBe(null);
});
test("rejects other non-numeric input", () => {
expect(parseDustThresholdGwei("lots")).toBe(null);
expect(parseDustThresholdGwei("+5")).toBe(null);
expect(parseDustThresholdGwei("Infinity")).toBe(null);
expect(parseDustThresholdGwei(undefined)).toBe(null);
expect(parseDustThresholdGwei(5)).toBe(null);
});
// Beyond 2^53 the digits would round on the way in, so the stored
// threshold would not be the one typed.
test("rejects a value too large to hold exactly", () => {
expect(parseDustThresholdGwei("9007199254740993")).toBe(null);
});
});
describe("the rejection message", () => {
// README, Language & Labeling: error messages are full sentences.
test("is a full sentence naming the constraint", () => {
expect(DUST_THRESHOLD_MESSAGE).toMatch(/^[A-Z].*\.$/);
expect(DUST_THRESHOLD_MESSAGE).toContain("whole number of gwei");
expect(DUST_THRESHOLD_MESSAGE).toContain("zero or greater");
});
});
describe("the flash line the message is shown in", () => {
const fs = require("fs");
const path = require("path");
const POPUP_HTML = fs.readFileSync(
path.join(__dirname, "..", "src", "popup", "index.html"),
"utf8",
);
// This asserts only that the reservation exists in the markup. It does
// NOT and CANNOT assert that the message fits inside it: jest runs on
// the node environment here, with no layout engine, so every rendered
// height is zero. An earlier version of this block claimed to pin the
// No Layout Shift policy with this regex, and it passed at any message
// length, including one that wrapped to two lines and pushed the
// settings view down 12px.
//
// The assertion that actually measures — empty line vs. the message,
// real Chromium, documented 360x600 popup — is
// "a rejected dust threshold shifts no layout (#233)" in
// tests/e2e/run.js, run by make test-e2e. It is not in make check
// because REPO_POLICIES.md caps make test at 20 seconds and a browser
// suite does not fit; run it before changing the wording.
test("reserves its height in the markup", () => {
const flashLine = POPUP_HTML.match(
/<div\s+id="flash-msg"\s+class="([^"]*)"/,
);
expect(flashLine).not.toBeNull();
expect(flashLine[1]).toMatch(/min-h-\[/);
});
});
describe("the settings view on a change to the field", () => {
let elements;
let flashes;
let saves;
let state;
// A stand-in for one DOM node: enough of an element for init() to set
// properties on it and hang listeners off it.
function fakeElement() {
return {
value: "",
checked: false,
textContent: "",
href: "",
style: {},
dataset: {},
classList: { add() {}, remove() {} },
listeners: {},
addEventListener(event, handler) {
this.listeners[event] = handler;
},
querySelectorAll: () => [],
};
}
function loadSettingsView() {
elements = {};
flashes = [];
saves = 0;
jest.resetModules();
jest.doMock("../src/popup/views/helpers", () => ({
$: (id) => (elements[id] ||= fakeElement()),
showView: () => {},
updateDebugBanner: () => {},
showFlash: (msg) => flashes.push(msg),
escapeHtml: (s) => s,
flashCopyFeedback: () => {},
goBack: () => {},
pushCurrentView: () => {},
onViewLeave: () => {},
VIEWS: [],
}));
state = require("../src/shared/state").state;
state.dustThresholdGwei = 100000;
const settings = require("../src/popup/views/settings");
settings.init({});
return elements["settings-dust-threshold"];
}
beforeEach(() => {
globalThis.chrome = {
runtime: { sendMessage: () => {} },
storage: {
local: {
get: async () => ({}),
set: async () => {
saves++;
},
},
},
};
});
afterEach(() => {
jest.dontMock("../src/popup/views/helpers");
delete globalThis.chrome;
});
async function change(field, typed) {
field.value = typed;
await field.listeners.change();
}
test("a valid value is stored and says nothing", async () => {
const field = loadSettingsView();
await change(field, "250");
expect(state.dustThresholdGwei).toBe(250);
expect(field.value).toBe(250);
expect(flashes).toEqual([]);
expect(saves).toBe(1);
});
test("a rejected value shows the message and is not stored", async () => {
const field = loadSettingsView();
await change(field, "1.5");
expect(state.dustThresholdGwei).toBe(100000);
expect(flashes).toEqual([DUST_THRESHOLD_MESSAGE]);
expect(saves).toBe(0);
});
// The snap-back is the behaviour the message explains, so it stays.
test("a rejected value still resyncs the field to what is stored", async () => {
const field = loadSettingsView();
await change(field, "100 gwei");
expect(field.value).toBe(100000);
});
test("every rejected notation gets the same one message", async () => {
for (const typed of ["", "-1", "1.5", "100 gwei", "0x10", "1e3"]) {
const field = loadSettingsView();
await change(field, typed);
expect(flashes).toEqual([DUST_THRESHOLD_MESSAGE]);
expect(state.dustThresholdGwei).toBe(100000);
}
});
test("zero is accepted, not treated as an empty field", async () => {
const field = loadSettingsView();
await change(field, "0");
expect(state.dustThresholdGwei).toBe(0);
expect(flashes).toEqual([]);
});
});